Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

What you like vs. what works: not always the same thing

November 14th, 2017 by Bob Bly

Subscriber DH writes:

“Bob, what are your favorite websites in terms of the copy they
have, so I can see myself which copy style you think is great?

“I was working for a client and came across a website from a
company that sells the same thing he does.

“I was blown away by the simple, fun, almost magical style of
their site vs. the more technical copy on my client’s site.

“But I wonder if I was right to admire the competitor site —
does that kind of copy draw customers?”

There are two key parts to the answer I gave DH.

The first is something copywriter Peter Beteul said that I never
forgot: “Don’t let personal preference get in the way.”

Meaning subjective judgment is absolutely the worst way to judge


Because countless marketing tests and many research studies prove
that there is no correlation between people liking an ad and
whether they buy the product.

Second, regarding DH’s websites, she has little or no access to
analytics and metrics measuring the website’s performance.

And results … not whether the site has a fun or “magical” style …
is what determines whether she should admire and emulate it.

In this case, she just doesn’t know. So following the competitor
site as a model would be questionable at best and unwise at

Back in the day, with print ads and direct mail, it was

Running newspaper and magazine ads, and doing postal direct mail,
is expensive.

And so marketers who use them test very carefully.

If an ad or direct mail test is not successful, they will not
repeat it.

On the other hand, an ad or mailing that is profitable is run
over and over until it stops making money.

So if you see an ad or mailing that runs continuously, you know
that copy is working — and in that case, it would be wise to

It’s pretty much the same for ongoing email campaigns and web
pages, although not as certain, because they are less expensive
to run than print — and therefore, are more forgiving of

One more point….

You only know whether someone else’s marketing is working if you
see the evidence with your own eyes, as indicated by frequency
and repetition.

If another marketer says response rates for their campaign are
through the roof, or that they are raking in money hand over
fist, the problem is you have no idea whether they are telling
you the truth.

As my good friend top info marketer Fred Gleeck says: “The only
numbers you can trust are your own.”


This entry was posted on Tuesday, November 14th, 2017 at 2:08 pm and is filed under Direct Marketing, Online Marketing. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

86 responses about “What you like vs. what works: not always the same thing”

  1. adaway apk said:

    this is one of the best app to download make use of adblocker

    adaway apk
    adaway apk download

  2. Sean said:

    The only numbers you can trust are your own.
    bullet force games

  3. Tobey said:

    What you like vs. what works is not always the same thing…

  4. ADfa said:

    Nice update

  5. alisha said:

    All the details are in this post is very interesting and brilliant and I am glad to see this post. Independent Escorts South Delhi

  6. sffsff said:

  7. mykfcexperience said:

    Great post. I like this post. Thanks for sharing this useful information.

  8. James said:

    FMovies: Watch Free Movies Online
    Best site to watch free movies online, just search your favorite full hd movies and enjoy.

  9. ritariya said:

    It’s my pleasure to see the post. It’s nice to see the blogs in the post. It had superlative contents. You have done a marvellous work. I really appreciate the work you have done. I feel so excited after seeing the post.It really admires me a lot. Thanks for sharing the post. I will share it with my friends. Keep sharing the updated posts.aba services los angeles

  10. adrian said:

    good article i like it very well.

    gomovies Watch Online movies for free

  11. Anna Shetty said:

    Pretty good post. I found your website perfect for my needs bullet force

  12. reenayh said:

    Pretty good post. free gift card codes generator excellent article.Great information, your post free gift card codes generator is really awesome!Thanks for free gift card codes generator You provide …

  13. mi ka said:

    This article was great, I read a lot of articles with this topic, but I found your article has a more impressive and detailed content, I hope you will have more interesting tracks more to bring to the reader, thank you for sharing.
    temple run 3

  14. Jimmy said:

    Pretty good post. I found your website perfect for my needs Game Answer

  15. javjke said:

    Great post. I like this post. Thanks for sharing this useful information.

  16. Alisa said:

    Nice blog. Fantastic! I love this much wheely 4 cool math

  17. John said:

    It is a great website.. The Design looks very good.. parking fury 3 cool math

  18. juropo said:

    thx you for this amazing info. avast-secureline-vpn-review

  19. aze as said:

    Android Apps Download

  20. Eyesight said:

    Balenciaga has introduced beautiful cat-eye style frames for ladies’ face shape. The product has an attractive look with compact arms to avoid failure from the nose. It has full plastic material in the whole frame with grey color to attract all. in this article, we’ll describe all specifications and parts details so you can easily determine the frame size and quality. For more details, scroll down the cursor and read all the information step by step. The product has repairable and exchange warranty with a specific time frame.

  21. Thestyledare said:

    Only problem with B is that woman can pee like that too. Really, we can. So is that a problem?
    hairstyle for women

  22. sohail said:

    very very wonderfull information thank you

  23. moviesapk said:

    Download the brand new Movies and TV Shows APK for free.

  24. quotesjin said:

    quotes for him and her go and check the FAKE FRIENDS QUOTES.

  25. thestyledare said:

    best hairstyle tips and idea are available here hairstyles for women

  26. rahul said:


  27. Norton Klanteservice said:

    Love and compatibility are not the same thing, though they are often confused for one another. Being intensely attracted to someone doesn’t always translate to a happy partnership. Getting along with someone doesn’t mean your relationship can blossom into romance if you just try hard enough and hope that desire will eventually come.

  28. Arthur Rodriguez said:

  29. Birdieli said:

    Thanks for the information, and thanks for the link, keep sharing this type of info KrogerFeed

  30. Patsy said:

    Do your research at Google

  31. Zeni Gupta said:

    The basic objective of an NGO is to support rural communities or un-development communities to uplift their living standards through strengthen local support institutions and conduct awareness sessions to cope with the development methodologies. To implement the above-mentioned targets in deprived communities, the following sections play a key role.

  32. jacob said:

  33. Max said:

  34. sammy said:

  35. fawmomasdsd said:

    Derek Chisora vs Joseph Parker bill on May 1, live on Sky Sports Box Katie Taylor fight live stream Office, with the return of Chris Eubank Jr and Dmitry Bivol’s WBA title defence against Craig Richards on the same blockbuster show.

  36. himanshu sharma said:

    Check this hot girl

  37. micro said:

    Thanks for sharing.
    Microg APK
    YouTube Vanced APK

  38. One Dasty said:

    We are dedicated to the breeding of the finest quality, sweet-tempered rough-coatide in the feedback received from purchasers of our puppies that their puppies have grown up to be very social and friendly adult dogs. This provides us with the necessary incentive to continue breeding these wonderful, loving and loyal companions.

  39. Gray said:

    All of Pitbull dog and puppy are sent home. Current on shots, deworming, flea treated, health certificate, genetic health guarantee, and AKC registration papers. All new families are required to sign a contract that includes a basic health guarantee and a 3 year genetic health guarantee. They have been raised in our home around small children, kittens and dogs of every size to help them develop well round personalities accustomed to daily home activates. We encourage families to ask question and to stay in contact with us.
    All puppies sold as pets will go home spayed-neutered! We also sell puppies along with breeding right. Note this will include an additional fee.

  40. robert said:

  41. sayase9339 said:

    192.168.ol is generally used as the default IP address of routers. It is a private IP address. Those who have routers with this IP address can use it to log in and change the internet settings for their routers.

  42. Ndure Shoes said:

    Working out without proper gym workout gloves can be tough, so use our gym gloves while you work out. NDURE brings you the best Gym Gloves available. Get High-Quality Gym Gloves for Men, including Training Gloves and Workout Gloves. NDURE has the best possible Gym Gloves in Pakistan just for you. Come to NDURE for all your gym needs.

    Ndure offers their customers the highest quality Mens jackets Pakistan of all types, including leather jackets and denim jackets. Get the best available Mens jackets in Pakistan. So, buy the Best Winter Jackets for Men from Ndure online. We bring you high-quality Jackets for men, without compromising on style and comfort.

    NDURE brings you its wide range of polo t-shirts men. Now you can buy your favorites with just a tap You can find our t shirts online by logging into our site Our shirts are made with pure fabric that makes you stand out So don t wait around and shop from our collection of online t shirts.

  43. Ndure Shoes said:

    Shop from a wide range of Mens collection from Ndure. Shop from a wide variety of men shoes online in Pakistan, Mens chappals, sandals, sneakers, sports wear, loafers, slipons and boots from Ndure. Our shoes are made from best quality material that is durable. Shop from a wide range shoes color and style. At Ndure, we have a fashion for each one of You.

  44. Ndure Shoes said:

    From Ndure buy online the latest fashion women track suits online at affordable price. Fast Shipping.

    Buy best quality comfortable ladies dri-fit training shirts for women online from Ndure. Fast Shipping.

    From Ndure buy the best quality wide leg trousers for women online at affordable price. Fast Shipping.

  45. said: IP address is the most popular and the default host address used to access the admin panel of a router. 192.168.l.l is a widely used private IP address by thousands of router brands around the globe. With which, the administrator can access the settings of their router and do a lot of stuff over there.

  46. Borjan Shoes said:

    Borjan offers its customers the best shoes for men in Pakistan. We have the highest quality men shoes and leather shoes in Pakistan for great prices. Get Borjan’s amazing collection of men’s shoes online. Get your favorite men’s shoes from Borjan to keep yourself in style and comfort at the same time.

  47. Jazmin said:

    Jazmin offers an amazing collection of ladies bottom wear such as capri designs. Grab these stylish and trendy bottoms online today from These women’s bottoms are sure to bring attention and improve your wardrobe. Jazmin offers the best bottom wear in Pakistan.

  48. Wisdom Pharma said:

    Wisdom Pharma offers you all the best self-care products in one convenient place, such as their dark circles creams. So, buy from Wisdom Pharma and get high-quality dark circle Creams online. Wisdom Pharma brings the best eye creams for dark circles in Pakistan.

  49. Feed kroger said:

    Thanks for the information, and thanks for the link, keep sharing this type of info

  50. yadongbiz said:

    Wonderful illustrated information. I thank you about that. No doubt it will be very useful for my future projects. Would like to see some other posts on the same subject! Feel free to visit my website;

  51. koreayadongcom said:

    everyone an extremely breathtaking chance to read from this blog. It is always so lovely and jam-packed with a great time. Feel free to visit my website;

  52. japanyadongcom said:

    It’s always a pleasure to read your magnificent articles on this site. You are among the top writers of this generation, and there’s nothing you can do that will change my opinion on that. My friends will soon realize how good you are. Feel free to visit my website;

  53. Beauty Tips said:

    Thanks for the information, and thanks for the link, keep sharing this type of info.

  54. ana said:

    This is a great article, and I appreciate you sharing it. That’s exactly what I was hoping to see, and I hope you’ll continue to share such great content in the future. poppy playtime

  55. mary said:

    It’s really knowledgeable information. I would like to appreciate this stuff. You can get some knowledge about Hyperfund Login here.

  56. Borjan Shoes said:

    Borjan is offering best women khussa shoes collections, our khussa for women are fashionable and premium quality product which will make your footwear fancy. We offer best design for ladies khussa online as well which are exclusively best quality product although khussa shoes for girls are our top-quality product for party wear.

  57. Rios Cosmetics said:

    Stunning best perfumes for men and perfume brands for men are offered by Rios, a great multi brand store The shop satisfies customers with the best perfumes for men in Pakistan Their best perfumes for men are perfect for your needs, fulfilling your demands With their perfumes for men, Rios meets all your requirements.

  58. Ndure Shoes said:

    Grab new pumpy shoes from Ndure today, mixing both style and comfort into a quality product.

  59. Chinyere said:

    Chinyere is one of the top ready to wear brands For the nomadic fashion spirit of now. We specialize in an exclusive collections of casual, semi formal and formal for your wardrobe. Our garments are designed with care and love to incorporate global fashion as well as tradition.

  60. Etisal said:

    Grab stylish scarves for women in Pakistan from Etisal. Their Scarves for Girls are trending in fashion Grab your favorite scarves from Etisal now. Etisal always fulfills your needs with amazing variety.

  61. Best Savings Coupon said:

    The effectiveness of a competitor’s writing can be judged by understanding the desires and needs of the target audience. With the mens wearhouse coupon, you can easily find the most effective writing style for your target audience.

  62. James Ronald said:

    It’s an amazing blog post, and it is really helpful as well.

  63. Local Electricians said:

    If you are looking for reliablestorage heater services,it is important to choose electricians who provide maintenance, installation services . My Local Electrician provides these all services.

  64. Local Electricians said:

    If you are looking for reliable storage heater services,it is important to choose electricians who provide maintenance, installation services . My Local Electrician provides these all services.

  65. Steven Markup said:

    The Philadelphia 76ers Classic Wool Varsity Jacket is a stylish way to show support for your team. Made from high-quality wool and featuring the team’s iconic colors, this jacket is perfect for fans who want to stay warm and look great. With its classic design and durable construction, it’s a must-have for any true 76ers fan.

  66. iHost VPS said:

    A virtual private server can be hosted in USA data center using the service. With our premier data centers and flexible packages, get quick and dependable vps hosting usa. Those who want faster website loading times and data protection standards may find this advantageous.

  67. Maples Closet said:

    Stylish and high-quality ladies leather bags that are both practical and lovely are available at Maples Closet. Our collection features crossbody bags, totes, and handbags manufactured from the best leather. Our leather bags are the ideal finishing touch for any ensemble, whether you’re dressing up or down. Shop right away to spruce up your outfit!

  68. Ericmonda said:

    Subscriber DH’s query raises an important point about the subjective nature of copy appreciation. While personal preference shouldn’t solely dictate judgment, the true measure lies in results. Copywriter Peter Beteul’s advice to avoid personal bias resonates here. Analyzing analytics and metrics is crucial in determining the effectiveness of a website. Just as a winch’s performance is evaluated through evidence, marketers must rely on their own numbers to gauge success. So, let’s trust in our own calculated strategies and be open to learning from others’ experiences.

  69. CaVPShost said:

    CaVps specializes in VPS hosting services within Canada. Our hosting solutions are specifically tailored to meet the needs of Canadian businesses and individuals, offering fast and reliable performance, robust security measures, and exceptional customer support. Host your website or application with us and experience the benefits of VPS hosting Canada.

  70. BSNS Consulting said:

    BSNS Consulting is a trusted digital marketing agency Lahore. With our expertise in digital marketing, we help businesses in Lahore enhance their online visibility, engage with their target audience, and drive measurable results through effective digital marketing campaigns.

  71. Hum Rahe said:

    Hum Rahe Na Rahe Hum Is Indain Tv Drama By Sony tv Hum Rahe Na Rahe Hum is Hindi Serial Tv
    Hum Rahe Na Rahe Hum

  72. Suhagan said:

    Suhagan Is Indain Tv Drama By Colors tv Suhagan is Hindi Serial Tv

  73. Dropwarez said:

    At Dropwarez, we understand that successful e-commerce ventures require effective store management. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources empowers you to efficiently handle inventory, process orders, and engage with customers. With Dropwarez Store Management, you’re equipped to streamline operations, provide exceptional customer experiences, and drive your online business to new heights.

  74. Tour Saint Lucia said:

    Discover the captivating islands of adventure rides with Tour Saint Lucia. Our expert-guided tours lead you through Saint Lucia’s most breathtaking landscapes, revealing hidden gems and scenic viewpoints. Immerse yourself in the charm of the Caribbean through our unforgettable island rides.

  75. emmasmith said:

    OBS Studio. , short for Open Broadcaster Software Studio, is a free and open-source software suite for video recording and live streaming. It’s a powerful tool commonly used by content creators, gamers, online broadcasters, and anyone who wants to create and share video content on platforms like Twitch, YouTube, Facebook Live, and more. OBS Studio is available for Windows, macOS, and Linux.

  76. BabyBoxShop said:

    Commemorate the miracle of life with our New Baby Gift Box. Bursting with love and well-wishes, this box is a heartfelt gesture to congratulate the new parents on their bundle of joy. From soft swaddles to charming onesies, each item encapsulates the joyous spirit of welcoming a new baby into the world. Share in the happiness with this thoughtful gift box.

  77. CAvpshost said:

    Welcome to CaVPS Host, your destination for the cheapest Windows Server hosting solutions! With our affordable plans and top-notch services, we guarantee a seamless hosting experience for your website or application. At CaVPS Host, we understand the importance of cost-effective solutions without compromising on quality. That’s why we offer the cheapest Windows Server hosting options available in the market. Our prices are designed to fit your budget, making it easy for small businesses, startups, and individuals to establish their online presence without breaking the bank.
    features, and excellent customer support.

  78. Vallee Real Estate said:

    Explore the historic charm and contemporary opportunities of real estate in New Westminster. From heritage homes along tree-lined streets to modern developments by the waterfront, this city offers a wide range of housing options. Find your ideal property and become a part of New Westminster’s vibrant community.

  79. Tiptop-Einrichtung said:

    A barberstuhl is a specialized chair used in barbershops. It is designed to provide comfort to male clients and facilitate optimal working posture for the barber.hese chairs often have a classic design and can be antique or retro-styled. Our skilled barbers provide precision cuts, classic shaves, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps our clients coming back for more.

  80. BSNS Consulting said:

    Trust BSNS Consulting as your reliable Taxation Services Provider. With our in-depth understanding of tax laws and regulations, we ensure accurate and timely tax compliance for your business. Our proactive tax planning approach aims to minimise tax burdens and maximise savings, allowing you to focus on driving your business forward.

  81. Tiptop-Einrichtung said:

    friseurstühle are the chairs available for clients in a hair salon. They are designed to be comfortable and allow the hairdresser easy access to the client’s hair.

  82. Vallee Real Estate said:

    Discover your dream townhouse for sale new westminster. Explore a range of attractive properties and find the perfect home for you in this vibrant city. Start your search today.Browse listings, explore amenities, and find the perfect townhome in this charming British Columbia community

  83. trwed3 said:

    Shop for Anime Store products online in Kharkiv, a leading shopping store for Anime Store products at discounted prices along with great deals and offers

  84. Vallee Real Estate said:

    A New Westminster realtor is a professional real estate agent or agency specializing in properties in the city of New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada. They assist buyers and sellers in navigating the local real estate market, offering their expertise in property transactions.

  85. Criminal Modz said:

    Elevate your adventure on GTA 5 modded accounts xbox one with Criminal Modz. We specialize in delivering meticulously crafted modded accounts tailored for the Xbox One platform. Our services open doors to a wealth of customized content, rare items, and an abundance of in-game cash. With a focus on trustworthiness and excellence, Criminal Modz is your go-to choice for secure Xbox One modded accounts.

  86. Tiptop-Einrichtung said:

    A Barbershop Bedienplatz is the workspace within a barbershop where haircuts, shaving, and other services for male clients are carried out. This area typically includes a chair, mirror, and tools.The Barbershop Service Station is the heart of every barbershop, where skilled barbers work their magic to create fresh looks and maintain well-groomed appearances. This dedicated area is thoughtfully designed for both the barber’s convenience and the client’s comfort.

Leave a Reply