Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

A Madison Avenue Ad Guy I Actually Like

May 4th, 2005 by Bob Bly

At first glance, Richard Kirshenbaum ? co-chairman of Kirshenbaum Bond & Partners ? is not my kind of guy.

He dresses too cool, has long hair, and runs a trendy NYC ad agency focusing on branding. Yuch!

So I was pleasantly surprised when, in an interview with Psychology Today (4/05, p. 34), he had this to day about humor in advertising:

?Humorous ads are troubling because you have to create a link to the product and its benefit. Often, people remember a funny ad but they don?t remember the product.?

I now have a growing admiration for Richard, and think his assessment is spot on ? really clever or funny ads become memorable as ads, but often do squat for product sales.

What do you think?


This entry was posted on Wednesday, May 4th, 2005 at 9:05 am and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

69 responses about “A Madison Avenue Ad Guy I Actually Like”

  1. Bruce DeBoer said:

    I think Richard is not the only one in the ad world who thinks this way: many do.

    He’s right.

    A funny ad that makes a connection to the brand is a home run though. The Nationwide ads tagged, “Life Comes at You Fast” is a good example of this. They are funny with a strong tie in.

  2. Peter Stone said:

    Humor is a very…very serious business. 🙂


  3. Peter said:

    Looking at the most recent Super Bowl series I’d say this is entirely true. Quite a few companies went gung-ho on one-dimensional “comedy” spots that didn’t make the connection between the humor and the product.

  4. Merely Human said:

    Effectiveness aside, I’ve noticed that even the memorability of humor in advertising is beginning to trail off. Have any of you seen the car ad with the men dressed up in black? They are all laying down face-up on a tan-colored surface when the ringleader says “Ok, Look alive!”, and they all stand straight up. The camera zooms out and all the men in black become little hairs on the driver’s arm demonstrating how exhilerating the ride is supposed to be. If you havn’t seen it, you probably can’t appreciate the surprising humor of it, but it caught me off guard and I don’t usually respond to humor in commercials. This one was cute. Anyways, I have a point. Two of them, actually. 1.) That after viewing that exceedingly clever bit of advertising a couple times now, I don’t even remember the name of the car featured in the ad. And 2.) that the ad (not the car) will remain memorable up until the point they stop playing it or another funny ad takes center stage in my short-term memory. And the cycle continues, with funny advertisements blunting the effectiveness of subsequent funny advertisements until they don’t even get noticed. Ever been around someone who’s overbearingly funny to the point of exhaustion? Yeah.

  5. Milton Drepaul said:

    I agree. One of the things that annoy me about some ads in Canada is the effort to be funny. People are sometimes thrown off because they cannot see the connection to the ad.
    I doubt whether a company wants to annoy a potential customer.

  6. Maeghan Killeen said:

    I seemed to remember quiznos well enough after their ads with those singing rat-like things. I think I even visted them once or twice afterward.

  7. Nataly Marshak said:

    Your topics attract thousand people. Free knowledge of world and life.
    And more!!!-freandship without borders.

  8. George Green said:

    Comment spam is problem of google and not only.

  9. Nick Adams said:

    I think we have problem.Spam is abnormal.To my mind we shall overcome.People are free.

  10. Natasha Naumova said:

    This is the travel of means.Thank you for the good time.

  11. Ivan Ivanov said:

    Latest World’s News

  12. John said:

    I will recomend this site… Excelent work!!! May I use your palette at my site?

  13. Terbitium said:

    ThChwg Hello Perdun! Google.

  14. Nelida Santano said:

    Congratulations to Chelsea on winning the FA Cup.

  15. website said:

    Whats the clearance within the loft?br /That lamp tends to make it glimpse as if it is about /Hunch again loft?

  16. stryker hip lawsuits said:

    Obtained h2o spots … use white vinger and a sponge … sponge it on & rinse it off … water spots disolve and that you are all set to wash … and prepare to clay, polish, & wax.

  17. bobinsds said:

    Logan Paul recently took to social media and trolled Floyd Mayweather, who he’s scheduled to face in a special exhibition Floyd vs Paul live fight on February 20, 2020. The YouTuber, who’s more than 6 feet tall, took aim at Mayweather’s 5ft 8in frame in a doctored picture. In the now-viral pic, Logan Paul can be seen looking down on the boxing legend, as he captioned the post 50 and oh my god he’s small. It will take place on Saturday, 20th February 2021.

  18. ???? ??? ???? ????? said:

    Your topics attract thousand people. Free knowledge of world and life.

  19. danomsd said:

    The 2021 Super Rugby season is the 26th season of Super Rugby, an annual Super Rugby live men’s international rugby union tournament organised by SANZAAR involving teams from Australia and New Zealand.

  20. pefabsds said:

    The 2021 IIHF World Championship is scheduled to take place from 21 May to 6 June 2021. It was originally to be co-hosted 2021 iihf world championship by Minsk, Belarus and Riga, Latvia, as the IIHF announced on 19 May 2017. Their joint bid won by a very tight margin against the Finnish bid with the cities of Tampere and Helsinki.

  21. Adela said:

    At this time generating sales is more harder than now few year ago for example, maybe the year that come will be more better. Who knows. Regards Divertisment

  22. tsdshgg said:

    Now, the New Zealander is fit again and has won his last Watch Chisora vs Parker Boxing four bouts. Chisora, meanwhile, lost to Oleksandr Usyk last October and will want to hit back.

  23. CIIS India said:

    Distance eductaion course Info
    A Master of Business Administration or MBA Distance Education from CIIS ensures that you can continue upgrading your skill set without worrying about attending regular classes. You can study at your own pace without compromising on quality education for the big stage in your professional career.

  24. Corwin said:

    Pugs for sale,pugs for sale near me,cheap pugs for sale,pug puppies for sale,pug puppies for sale near me,teacup pug,pug for sale,teacup pugs for sale,teacup pugs,pug puppy for sale texas,pug puppy for sale az,pug puppy for sale arkansas,pug puppy for sale atlanta,pug puppy for sale adelaide,pug puppy for sale australia,pug puppies for sale alberta,pug puppies for sale austin texas,

  25. pofesdwsd said:

    British and Irish Lions head coach Warren Gatland is set to name his 36-man squad live stream Lions tour 2021 for the tour to South Africa this summer to take on the World Champion Springboks.

  26. robert said:

  27. william sonalford said:

    Useful information from your article. Develop the content further to improve the shortcomings super mario bros

  28. tassesds said:

    The Alabama Crimson Tide football program Where can I watch the Alabama game for free? represents the University of Alabama in the sport of American football.

  29. geometry dash said:

    Great information, thanks for sharing!

  30. Lingayas said:

    Humour is not just a pleasant way to spend some easy time, there’s more to it – more than something that just amuses one…

    by the way.. find Is m tech distance education valid?

  31. rubbendias said:

    Thanks for your share, you can play word game online on: nytimes spelling bee
    nytimes spellingbee

  32. xefasdsd said:

    After failing to secure fights with division standouts Brian Castano Tim Tszyu next fight and Tony Harrison, WBO super welterweight contender Tim Tszyu has announced.

  33. jewomosds said:

    The All Blacks first played against Italy at the opening game Italy vs NZ Rugby Game of the inaugural Rugby World Cup in 1987, beating them 70-6 at Eden Park, Auckland.

  34. befasds said:

    The national rugby union teams of France and New Zealand have been All Blacks vs France rugby tv free playing each other for over a century as of 19 October 2015, they have played 56 Test matches against each other.

  35. deravesd said:

    Robert Whittaker is set to fight on the biggest weekend of the American UFC 271 time sporting calendar, with his UFC 271 blockbuster against Israel Adesanya coinciding with NFL Super Bowl festivities.

  36. EssayUK said:

    Agreed on one thing that annoys me about some ads in the UK is the effort to be funny. Individuals are occasionally thrown off because they cannot see the relation to the ad. The same situation happens in writing essays. Students get low marks because they fail to make relevancy may be due to a lack of knowledge so students hire to write my assignment firm to get excellent essay in low prices.

  37. viwiyosds said:

    BMX started during the mid 1970s in the United States when kids started bmx championships live coverage hustling their bikes on soil tracks in southern California, roused by the motocross stars of the time.

  38. somsdsd said:

    The chap has had everything laid with a royal flair in his boxing SBW vs Hall vocation to date. Sonny Boy has committed an error in taking this battle.

  39. cocoyisds said:

    Ring legend Floyd Mayweather will contend in his third show session How to watch Belhasa vs Mayweather Jr on BT TV since his expert retirement as he faces YouTube star Money Kicks one month from now.

  40. My job consultancy said:

    Nice information .Its helpfully to everyone.The type of training offered may depend on the type of consulting firm and its size. Consulting firms have high demands on potential candidates: Most jobs require at least a college degree or university degree, as well as certain skills and abilities. Another, and perhaps most common, reason companies hire consultants is to acquire a set of specialized skills that may not be available in-house. More recently, consulting has become a source of talent for companies recruiting for leadership positions.

  41. fdgsafsasa said:

    The governing body for the mini games is the Pacific Games Council. live stream XI Pacific Mini Games 2022 Much like the main games, the Games council flag is presented to the host nation of the next mini games at the end of every games.

  42. undertess146 said:

    Taco Bell is an American-based chain of fast-food restaurants originating in Irvine, California. It was founded in 1962 by Glen Bell, and Taco Bell is a subsidiary of Yum brands, Inc.

    The Taco Bell restaurants serve a variety of Mexican-inspired foods that include: nachos, quesadillas, tacos, burritos, novelty, and specialty items, along with a variety of “value menu” items.

  43. How can I stream live Golf? said:

    They get enrollment on the PGA Tour for the accompanying five seasons and on the European Tour for the accompanying seven seasons. The PGA Championship is the only one of the four majors that is solely for proficient players.

  44. acronis cyber backup pricing said:

    Blog like this should get more popularity rather than those who publish garbage content. Best of luck. If you are looking to prepare your company to take on difficult situations, you should to be equipped by Acronis on-line backup.


    It is an articulated and thought-provoking article. I got consumed while reading it. It compelled me to think about the things I never thought of before. If you’re looking for an East looking house Vastu plan, then you’ve come to the right spot. After receiving a positive response from home buyers to our Vastu house with a west-facing view and after being asked by many to offer Vastu plans for an East facing home.

  46. sdsdsds said:

    Hong Kong, which played had a significant influence in the worldwide watch rwc 7s online advancement of the Sevens game, facilitated the occasion. The last was won by Fiji over South Africa.

  47. cicesdsdasds said:

    They will be the main the M?ori All Blacks have played since facilitating Maori vs Ireland the British and Irish Lions in Rotorua. Ireland are positioned fourth on the planet under mentor Andy Farrell.

  48. Real Estate Agent In Long Island said:

    Our experienced team is considered one of the best in the real estate market. We assist you in selling your houses at the best rates. You can list yourHouses for Sale in Long Island on our website. We offer rental services as well so you can rent your beautiful homes. Here are a few tips to help how one can sell their home.

  49. mixoyesds said:

    He added It’s been a difficult stretch for us all and I’ve lost companions through emotional wellness. Presently we’ve nearly come out the opposite end it will be something Where to watch Hatton vs Barrera pleasant to accomplish for the fansand more like a celebration than a boxing show. Ideally it can likewise show individuals what they can accomplish on the off chance that they simply get off their couches and put themselves out there.

  50. Real Estate Agent In Long Island said:

    Real estate Agent In Long Island provides the greatest services for property selling and buying. Both can be time-consuming. We attempt to save you time while also offering the finest pricing in town. We assist you in discovering gorgeous places in popular areas.

  51. Seran said:

    Seran is the choice for women Ready to Wear 2022 dresses make your outfit collections trendy and fancy by wearing seran dresses.

  52. TheCareer-Coach said:

    Interview Preparation If you’ve already managed to polish off your CV to stand out – congratulations! If you haven’t, check out our Jobseeker Plan here to check out our all-inclusive plan for those looking for their first job or their next job!

  53. Shanewotts said:

    Striping is integral on roads and parking spaces. Line striping gives a clear sense of direction to the drivers in following the traffic rules on the roads and highways. In the parking areas, the thermoplastic striping Houston Thermoplastic Striping helps manage the space properly and directs the inflow and outflow of the traffic.

  54. Ndure Shoes said:

    One of the leading shoes brands in Pakistan is Ndure, always offering their customers quality footwear.

  55. Alexpeter said:

    The Career Coach is Europe’s top career coaching consultancy – and has helped more than 10,000 people land their dream jobs, all in less than 40 days.

  56. Shanewotson said:

    PSW is an Asphalt Contractors Houston that uses extreme crack repair fillers for structure resurfacing to prevent the unwanted penetration of water and moisture and weed growth.

  57. Hazel James said:

    Ecommerce Website Design Services and we design a manageable, user-friendly, and mobile-friendly e-commerce website and custom websites that will get your business rolling without putting a dent in your pocket.

  58. Dr. Ganesh Dubey said:

    I dissent from many of the ideas you mentioned, but still eager to read more such content. Keep going, and best of luck.

  59. Rios Cosmetics said:

    Stunning cleaning wipes and hand cleaner wipes are offered by Rios, a multi brand retailer. The shop wants to give customers delight by offering top notch goods like Hand Wipes. Their cleaning wipes is perfect and precisely what you require With their products like hand cleaner wipes, Rios satisfies all of your needs.

  60. beyaysdsd said:

    Everything begins with the spinetingling sound of Hen Wlad Fy Nhadau, Watch All Blacks vs Wales 2022 online and the Welsh Hwyl that we are renowned for around the World Ensure you can be important for the environment.

  61. Sifa pk said:

    Are you looking for sale on brands in Pakistan? So come to Sifa online and get a sale on the latest dresses with discounted prices in all over Pakistan.

  62. RobertHalf said:

    Custom eCommerce website development but also take into account the technical side too. We develop a website with SEO-optimized content, faster loading time, interactive features, and a mobile-friendly layout to improve user experience.

  63. leyasasa said:

    Britain beat the All Blacks in a World Cup semi last in Japan. By and large, Watch All Blacks vs England online Britain and New Zealand have played each other on events since their most memorable gathering. The All Blacks have won matches, while Britain have won eight matches.

  64. gilbert said:

    Best Shisha in Ireland offers you a wide range of shisha with flavourful drinks to go with it. Bring in your friends and family and enjoy the secluded atmosphere we offer you. We are offering amazing deals on drinks and shisha combos throughout the week.

  65. Stellar Website Designing said:

    Stellar has developed websites for numerous national and worldwide companies, start-up businesses, and even major organizations.

    Click here:- Web Design in Delhi

  66. MRM Unique Homes said:

    MRM Unique Homes is the best PG for girls in Anand Niketan Delhi. We provide Fully Furnished AC Rooms with Hygienic food, Wi-Fi, TV, CCTV & House Keeping services,

  67. Marriage Hall in Sahibabad said:

    I bookmarked your website to get future reads. I hope you will keep posting such articles. Plan your family occasions with luxurious Banquet hall in Sahibabad, Ghaziabad or host your Wedding, Pre Wedding at our Banquet halls.

  68. Hypeverse said:

    Hypeverse is Your One Stop Shop For All Types Of Sneakers Online In India. Explore a Wide Range Of Sneakers Which Includes Yeezy, Jordans & Dunks. Hypeverse Allows You To Buy, Sell & Bid On Your Favourite Sneakers Securely With Guaranteed 100% Authenticity.

  69. Read more said:

    This academy is renowned for its innovative curriculum and state-of-the-art facilities, but what truly sets it apart is its emphasis on fostering excellence, creativity, and innovation.

Leave a Reply