Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

Am I a book publishing snob?

October 18th, 2013 by Bob Bly

I’m afraid that when I tell you what I am about to tell you, you’ll either be offended or think I’m a jerk.

But, because I always tell you the complete and unvarnished truth about the subjects we discuss, I’m going to go ahead and tell you anyway.

So here it goes: for more years than I can count, I secretly looked down upon people who self-published their books.

I was a mainstream book publishing elitist and snob.

Before you start throwing rotten tomatoes at me or call me a philistine, remember that I grew up in the traditional book publishing world … and so that was what I knew and loved.

If I had self-published my first book, I might well have become a self-publishing cheerleader.

But as it happened, when I wrote my first book proposal in 1981, the first agent I took it to agreed to represent it … and the first publisher he showed it to, McGraw-Hill, bought it for an $8,500 advance (and it was a short book).

For all my books since then … more than 80 to date … I have had them published by mainstream publishing houses including John Wiley & Sons, HarperCollins, Henry Holt, Prentice Hall, and New American Library.

I always preferred traditional publishing to self-publishing for these reasons:

1—It was a lot less work. I only had to write the book. The publisher took care of designing, printing, storing, shipping, and selling it.

2—It cost me nothing out of pocket. And it paid me immediate income – an advance – even before the book was published.

3—There was much more prestige in those days being published by a “real” publishing house than by having it printed at your own expense.

At least one famous self-publishing guru disputes me on this. He says: “The reader doesn’t look to see or care about who published the book; he only cares who the author is and what the book is about.”

From years of personal experience, I can tell you flat-out that this isn’t true — and people are more impressed when you are published by a traditional publisher … regardless of whether they should be.

Once, when I was giving a speaking engagement, one of the attendees volunteered to chauffer me from the airport to the convention center – because, he told me, doing so would give him some private time with me.

“So you’ve written 35 books?” he asked me. “Yep,” I replied.

“Self-published them, I suppose,” he said lightly, but I could hear the undertone of something like mockery or mild denigration in his voice.

“Nope,” I snapped backed proudly and confidently. “My publishers are McGraw-Hill, Prentice Hall, and Wiley.”

He looked at me with newfound respect, and the only reason was that in his eyes I was now a “real” author instead of a guy that paid to have his scribbling printed and bound.


This entry was posted on Friday, October 18th, 2013 at 1:57 pm and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

71 responses about “Am I a book publishing snob?”

  1. Jen @ Daycare In Demand said:

    Great post, Bob–while there are definitely valid business reasons to self-publish, in certain circumstances, there is still nothing like the validation of having a bona fide publisher put out your books. As a reader, I DO care who publishes your book, especially since the quality of self-published books tends to be lower.

    A personal pet peeve of mine is when the “self” part of the publishing is swept under the rug by the author–again, nothing wrong with it, but it’s not the same as officially “being published” and shouldn’t be treated as such.

  2. Josh Lugembe said:

    Bob, 80+ books is such a great work.

    And by the way, I guess I’ve to tell you that I found about when I was reading the third edition of Get Clients Now by C. J. Hayden.

    As far as copywriting, I’m only taking the first few steps. And I’m hoping and determined to make it large just like you.

    I have bookmarked your site and blog, and that means I will be returning here for more.

    Thank you for inspiration.

  3. Bob Bly said:

    Jen: I agree 100%. Paying a printer to print your book is NOT equivalent to having a major NYC publishing house pay you an advance to publish your book.

  4. Steve Beedie said:

    Hey Bob,

    Great post and i have to admit i am in the middle of a really tough battle with myself regarding the route to market for my book.

    I’ve got a traditional agent and even a ghost writer whom both could’t sell my work. Of course i know I’m not the greatest writer or author but I’m not the worst either.

    It’s been a hard slog trying to get an traditional house to publish my work. It’s in personal development. i’ve been on TV radio and helped charities to raise millions for their needs. My story has been helping thousands across the world recover from PTSD (im ex army myself) and i have some good buddies in the internet marketing world who are happy to help me promote my work.

    But still trying to get someone to look at my work is proving painful.

    I’ve really thought about going down the self published route via kindle and even had a NY self publishing house ask me for $5000 to start printing my books. It all seems a bit mad.

    Does it come down to the book, or does it have to come down to finding a great agent?

    Would love to hear your thoughts.

    Awesome post and will be coming back.

    Off to buy some of your books 🙂



  5. Diana Schneidman said:


    I fully support self-publishing and I’m going that route myself.

    However, I will say that it is being cheapened by people who are using it to publish crap. I’m seeing books of perhaps 35 pages. I’m seeing gurus who help people write books in a week or even a weekend. I’m seeing books that are written to serve as glorified business cards—we can no longer assume that because someone “wrote the book” on a subject that they are really experts.

    The buyer truly has to beware. It’s quite possible for a book to be priced as low as $2.99 or even 99 cents and not be worth the expenditure.


  6. James Altucher said:

    Bob, I agree that for the most part of the past 100 years, having a traditional publisher was the way to go. My first five books were with traditional publishers.

    I won’t argue for or against them. There’s pros and cons.

    Two things changed for self-publishing just in the past five years.

    A) POD. You mention that self-publishing requires you to pay someone to print your books. THis is not longer true. That form of vanity pubishing is largely gone. Publish through Amazon and its print-on-demand. They print when someone orders.

    B) Kindle. Before the kindle (and other ebook readers) you had to get distribution through a mainstream house. They have specific divisions set up for this. If you don’t sell through them, you will never get in the bookstore.

    But Kindle solved the distribution issue. Most books sold now are ebooks.

    Some minor issues:

    A) Advances are great. No argument. But so are 70% royalties (self-publish) vs 15% royalties. And 100% international rights vs 50%. Now, this doesn’t apply to everyone. You need to be a “professional” self-publisher and know what you are doing. But most professional writers now should probably at least weigh the alternatives.

    My last self-published book was/is a bestseller. Just crossed the 100,000 in sales mark and has sold rights in about 10+ countries.

    One other important factor: I can make deals. So I bundle my self-published books in various ways and make A LOT more money per sale than I would with a traditional publisher who probably would not have the business savvy to do what I do.

  7. strategic book marketing said:

    Whether you were looking for pricing options or additional details, there is a pretty
    great chance that a market already exists for the product line you are promoting.
    By reading marketing book awards high quality network marketing
    books can be very handy. According to Yarnell’s network marketing books.
    Even if you are really predisposed to create your book e-mail ad in
    Microsoft Word, then save it as HTML; however, you should avoid this practice.
    His style has been simple, lucid, skill based and above all adaptable in practical

  8. szybka pozyczka internetowa said:

    Really when someone doesn’t understand afterward its up to other visitors
    that they will help, so here it takes place.

  9. Patricia Ferr said:

    I am curious to find out what weblog system you happen to be working with? I?m having some minor security troubles with my latest blog and I?d like to uncover something much more safe. Do you might have any recommendations?

  10. Jésus Clay said:

    Discussão bem interessante, tb penso em publicar meu livro logo logo, e os canais mudaram desde então.

  11. detran mg said:

    Great discussion, I Learn very much.

  12. detran pr said:

    Publications today serves more digital aspect than physical, at least that’s what I’ve noticed.

  13. detran ba said:

    very interesting discussion. I prefer the physical.

  14. detran-ipva said:


  15. gerador de cpf said:

    Thanks for the knowledge.
    My other job is the Site Gerador de CPF Válido/ Gerador de Pessoas.

  16. Mp3 Download said:

    OK, now

  17. Mp4 Download said:

    Mp4 HD, now you

  18. mr vinny said:

    it’s was very nice info. i really like it

  19. Happy Easter Images said:

    Please i’ll would like to understand just in case you are snared in to A mastermind for your web site. you mix some appallingly tight substance, which I do trust i’ll be spoken to as a legit property. ought to anybody within the past would like a various strain off, i would like to record some materials for your web site in exchange for a web affiliation back once more to mine. it might be ideal if you image conifer categorical a contact whenever intrigued. a lot of appreciated an out of this world arrangement an honest arrangement heaps.

  20. aweegweagwegwa said:

    Hi! somebody in my very own special Facebook bunch allotted this information getting ready framework around, therefore I landed to deliver it a glance. i’m obtaining a charge out of the data. i’m bookmarking and you may be tweeting this to my fans! mammoth diary and good vogue and magnificence.

  21. said:

    Here is the most awaited version for pc

  22. loveback mantra said:

    very interesting discussion

  23. BrunoA said:

    You should do a poetry analysis essay before you gonna publish a book. Keep an eye on it!

  24. Dgreetings08 said:

    Children’s Day is celebrated across the world on different dates in various countries. Universal Children’s Day is marked in November, while International Children’s Day is observed on June first.

    Turkey in 1920 was first to discover the International Children’s Day and then by Switzerland in 1925.

  25. leona said:

    I think that traditional publishing is better than self-publishing .because if it is traditional publishing we only need to write it and all the other aspects will be done by the publishing house. seo companies in kerala if it is self-publishing if the book doesn’t get crack in the market we will surely lose a huge amount of money.

  26. said:

    Thanks for sharing nice information about 3 main parts to construction the distribution transformers. It is so important. keep sharing.

  27. Najnas said:

    Very interesting to read this article. I am hoping that you will continue writing this kind of website. Digital marketing agency Kochi Thanks for sharing.

  28. Jindev said:

    Topic is nice and I appreciate it . corporate gifts in Kochi . it’s an amazing post, i like it very much

  29. Lenny said:

    I love reading books and already have huge collections of books in my room. Besides this I running my business online where I provide information about home tools because people often purchase tools without any information & pick tools with lesser uses, I recommend for such people who desperately buy tools please have a glimpse and make your selection perfect and under budget.Thanks

  30. Peter Parker said:

    I like the way you written your article. I am offering this site to find your ZIP Code without getting any trouble. You may visit given site to find your ZIP Code.

  31. David said:

    If you wanna know Cardiac arrest then visit

  32. ZIP Codes said:

    I found your post interesting to read. Good Luck with the upcoming update. This article is very interesting and effective.

  33. mapquest driving directions said:

    Oh, great, your article provided me with useful information and a fresh perspective on the subject. mapquest driving directions

  34. malumaat said:

    kia bat hai veery chah gya Toyota Fortuner 2021

  35. scp 096 said:

    Thank you very much for writing such an interesting article on this scp 096

  36. nytimes spellingbee free said:

    Nytimes spellingbee is a free online words game, free game puzzles online, try to play and be the best. have fun. thanks all.

  37. h202 error quickbooks said:

    Great article lots of information in very simple and descriptive language. However, let us talk about Quickbooks and a particular error H202 that causes a problem directly to the company’s file if not removed at a proper time. You need all the information you can access before you try to remove this error otherwise you will lose the company files and will not be able to recover them.

  38. toydibus said:

  39. aquapenta said:

    Wow! Your new website looks amazing. Thanks for sharing it. I found this Information very interesting and informative! Keep sharing! Water treatment companies in kochi

  40. sara said:

    Your topic is receiving a lot of followers and so am I. Thank you for sharing. construction companies in Oman

  41. bodhini said:

    Nice post. I was constantly checking this blog and I am impressed!

  42. jain said:

    Your blog is really very nice, informative and thorough.I really appreciate your hard work. online cyber safety programs in Kerala

  43. jins said:

    This is completely a piece of new information for me. Thank you for sharing this article with us. I have also bookmarked your site as one of my favorite sites.
    child Help Foundation in Kerala

  44. najnasya said:

    Nice post. I was constantly checking this blog and I am impressed. Thank you for sharing this article with us.
    NGO in Kerala

  45. One Dasty said:

    Bringing a pug puppy or French Bulldog puppy is hard work. Making sure they are raised and trained properly can be overwhelming at first, but by offering our customers a great amount of support, we assist in the preparations to make it less stressful. To provide a completely different environment for our puppies, we thoroughly researched and make sure this puppies will only go to respectable families

  46. McOrlando said:

    All of Pitbull dog and puppy are sent . Current on shots, deworming, flea treated, health certificate, genetic health guarantee, and AKC registration papers. All new families are required to sign a contract that includes a basic health guarantee and a 3 year genetic health guarantee. They have been raised in our home around small children, kittens and dogs of every size to help them develop well round personalities accustomed to daily home activates. We encourage families to ask question and to stay in contact with us.
    All puppies sold as pets will go home spayed-neutered! We also sell puppies along with breeding right. Note this will include an additional fee.

  47. robert said:

  48. where to get eyelash extensions in colorado springs .. said:

    Be proud!

  49. lash extensions seattle wa.. said:

    You made it!!

  50. Restaurants in Hunza said:

    This is proudable.

  51. Ndure Shoes said:

    The best wide leg trousers for women are in town only at Ndure Log onto our site or visit our stores to get your hands on the best women s trousers suitable for all occasions Each trouser is manufactured keeping in mind comfort, luxury, and ease, casual hangouts Ndures trousers for women are the key to every day comfortability.

  52. himanshu sharma said:

    check this hot girl

  53. ankit said:

    Check the cutest girl out here

  54. Go Matka said:

    Very Informative article. Nice to read.
    Satta Matka App Development
    Matka Game App Development
    Matka app development

  55. Chinyere said:

    Buy women apparels from chinyere, which is best women clothing brands in pakistan providing wide variety of women apparels in Pakistan.

  56. evden eve nakliyat izmir said:

    Evden eve nakliyatta guven ve kalite bir arada. izmir evden eve nakliyat evden eve nakliyat izmiristanbul izmir evden eve nakliyat

  57. Rivaj UK said:

    Rivaj offers great cosmetics and related products like makeup remover and makeup remover wipes So, grab the best makeup remover from Rivaj today and enjoy Their makeup remover kits are truly unbeatable and offer a high degree of satisfaction Rivaj offers the best makeup remover to their customers every day

  58. mitgroup said:

    I have read your article, it is really interesting and has lots of useful information. I also recommend it to friends so they can read it and they see the same thing. <a href=""Network security providers in Abu Dhabi

  59. mitgroup said:

    I have read your article, it is really interesting and has lots of useful information. I also recommend it to friends so they can read it and they see the same thing. Telecom services in Abu Dhabi

  60. Rivaj UK said:

    Rivaj brings amazing cosmetics and related products like lip gloss accessories and lip gloss colours So, grab the long lasting hydrated best lip gloss in Pakistan from Rivaj today and enjoy Their Lip gloss products are truly unbeatable and offer a high degree of satisfaction Rivaj offers the best Lip Gloss to their customers every day

  61. Rivaj UK said:

    Grab amazing cosmetics and related products like primer makeup and the best primer, only from Rivaj So, grab their best primers today and enjoy Their primer makeup sets are truly unbeatable and offer a high degree of satisfaction Rivaj offers the best primer makeup to their customers all the time

  62. jhon set said:

    Service representatives work extensively with complex telephone systems and often route calls to appropriate representatives with an organization. Certificacion CE Coche

  63. Borjan Shoes said:

    Borjan offers its customers the best shoes for men in Pakistan. We have the highest quality mens shoes and leather shoes in Pakistan for great prices.

  64. jhon bill set said:

    What could be better? Of course you might just try to summon up the energy to pick up your golf clubs and have a game at the excellent Pollensa Golf Club, not far from Porto Pollensa on the Pollensa Highway mejores sitios españa

  65. Rivaj UK said:

    Grab amazing cosmetics and related products like primer makeup and the best primer, only from Rivaj So, grab their best primers today and enjoy Their primer makeup sets are truly unbeatable and offer a high degree of satisfaction Rivaj offers the best primer makeup to their customers all the time

  66. Rios Cosmetics said:

    Perfect foot scrapers and foot filers are offered by Rios, a multi brand retailer The shop wants to give customers delight by offering top notch goods like the best foot filer Their foot scrapers are perfect and precisely what you require With their products like foot filer, Rios satisfies all of your needs.

  67. izmir su ARITMA said:


  68. jhon bill set said:

    Generally, this will bring on emotional pain. There are reasons we maintain cords with others. We must look at what it is we need or want that is creating these unwanted cords. Dryer A Adapter

  69. Mike Rooney said:

    Awesome blog. I have read and thought about what you said. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!
    Warriors Vest

  70. charlie ford said:

    How do you know if you’re gay? There’s a whole spectrum of romantic and sexual orientation, and ultimately, you get to choose whatever label feels right.

  71. experience makers said:

    Thanks for sharing wonderful information and giving the best information. it’s more useful and more helpful. great doing keep sharing
    Wedding planners in Kochi

Leave a Reply