Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

Content vs. Branding

June 29th, 2007 by Bob Bly

My colleagues Michael Stelzner and David Scott Meerman are, like me, advocates of marketing with content.

But a recent article suggests that our approach is all wrong.

The author said that branding is more effective than ever today.

Reason: prospects are suffering from information overload. They don’t have time to process product information. And so they make purchase decisions based on brand reputation rather than product facts.

Well, hey, if that’s true, then prospects don’t want — or have time to read — more content, right?

So which should a marketer concentrate on?

Becoming a thought leader by publishing valuable content?

Or branding?


This entry was posted on Friday, June 29th, 2007 at 8:28 am and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

50 responses about “Content vs. Branding”

  1. Susan Martin said:

    Another great question Bob. I think that there may be different answers depending on what you’re selling and the size of your business.

    But ultimately aren’t we achieving the same thing just approaching it differently?

    I’m sure that apple will sell many iphones because of the incredible brand they’ve built, and that marketing with content will not play a large part in it, if any, although all of the buzz that’s been created does create content, even if it’s not generated by apple themselves.

    It doesn’t have to, they’re already there and will stay there as long as they consistently support the brand they’ve built with new, unique products and maintain a certain level of customer service.

    But if you’re selling a service, marketing with content can be very effective, by helping to position you and your firm as experts.

    I think when someone is having a problem and they seek out information on how to solve it, it’s different than when someone is being bombarded with excess information. It’s all about how you do it.

    But isn’t establishing that “expert” reputation just another way of building your brand?

  2. Deborah Chaddock Brown said:


    I love branding messages. I laugh with the commercials that are fun and memorable. I chuckle over who is wearing the milk mustache. But when it comes to making a buying decision – the cute and clever messages based solely on branding don’t give me the information I need to change my behavior or part with my money. I may think the caveman commercials for Geiko are memorable but would I switch insurance companies based on what I see in the commercials? No.

    And the words have to connect with me. I don’t want to hear about quality, price and selection – frankly those are a given – the price of admittance. I want to know that you GET me, that you UNDERSTAND my pain, you CONNECT with my needs and you’ll PROVIDE the solutions to make my life easier, better, safer, whatever.

    You aren’t going to do that with a branding message alone. Not in my book. When I think successful branding image, I think Target. Seeing the red circle connects with my prior shopping experiences. I see the red circle and I remember a clean environment, helpful employees, nice selection, reasonable prices.

    I can’t think of another company as successful with a branding message – bottom line – I need words.

    Deborah Chaddock Brown

  3. Kevin Behringer said:


    Very interesting question.

    I don’t think that strong content will ever go away as a preferred method of marketing. I think branding is critical, but often built BY strong content. To use Susan’s example of the iPhone, yes it gets a lot of press from the fact that it’s an Apple product…part of a strong brand. But, if it didn’t do all of the things it does (in my mind…that’s the content) would it get the same press. I doubt it. If it was simply a cell phone with Apple’s name on it, it wouldn’t do.

    I think there needs to be a strong connection between branding and content. In fact, brands are often built by the content…at least the good ones. The days of hiding poor content with fancy branding are over (or should be!). Thank God!

  4. Bobby Lehew said:

    Both. It’s not an either/or proposition, they are not mutually exclusive. I think Susan is right: establishing that expert reputation is another way of building your brand, both play a part in the process. Branding is intriguing; thought leadership is inviting.

  5. Michael A. Stelzner said:

    I heard someone calling my name…

    Bob, I would have to agree that prospects are suffering from information overload…

    HOWEVER, that makes the job of copywriting ever MORE important.

    “Me too” writing will drown in the sea of excess.

    I think now what matter is relevance more than brand.

    It helps to be known, but in the BtoB world, often businesses buy from people/other businesses they have never heard of.

    AND, good content can actually help a business become a thought leader and improve branding.

    Thanks for pulling me in.

  6. Riel Langlois, writer of Canadian comic books said:

    Right now, I think branding is more important. You’re right about information overload – I tend to focus on brand names I trust rather than compare reviews of similar products.

  7. Leslie McKerns said:

    Branding has become popular because it is seen as a higher level of commitment. (We will ALWAYS do thus and so–freshest, fastest, most compassionate, you name it.)But once you do name it – you had better deliver. Branding is ultimately about the customer experience. You create a set of expectations and then deliver on it. If you don’t, the brand is dead or dying, no matter how cute the logo. When a brand delivers on expectations it has created it becomes memorable and recognizable (because it has consistently delivered on those expectations). Here a few examples:

    Let’s look at Ron Popeil’s Ronco Company. What is he saying? He’s saying: Come on live a little; have some fun with gadgets. And he gets that customer to be engaged–to buy into the experience as well as buy the product. His Showtime Rotisserie–Set it and Forget it. Set it and…what? And the audience roars…forget it!!!

    This is a far different experience than the sophistication and culinary seriousness of say, a Williams and Sonoma or a Sur La Table. They are saying, You can’t possibly attempt to do this properly without this stainless steel masterpiece. And you believe it because the outcome matters to you–it is your boss or mother in law coming for a sit down dinner party or Thanksgiving.

    So, you think what is the outcome I want them to have? (with my product or service) and you deliver on that in everything you say or do–your newsletter, your catalog.

    Are we serious or are we fun? If you are BMW and branding yourself as the Ultimate Driving Machine…you better have some sophisticated experientials to back that up–the showroom, the brochures, the ads…as well as a smooth driving performance vehicle. Or the first time I pull out in front of a truck on I-95 and I barely beat it–I’m going to be more than disappointed, I’m going to be returning it to the showroom.

  8. Lori said:

    I’m from the old school – words sell. Yes, branding works, but without words, whaddya got? I don’t buy M&Ms because they added blue to their “menu” – I buy them because they promise to melt in my mouth, not in my hand. That and the fact that I like chocolate…

    I have to agree that branding requires more attention to copy than at first glance. Case in point – I was asked recently to review a new product being considered for the market. They were tired – scented tires. The copy was shmaltzy at best; “You demand the best perfume, ladies! Why not the best smelling tires?!” Uh, how about because I don’t go around sniffing tires like a beagle with a full bladder? It was the case of a ridiculous product that was made worse by copy that insulted its intended audience. Why the hell would we women care if our tires emitted a lovely lavender scent? We want to know if the damn things are going to last!


  9. David Fideler said:

    “Branding” and “content” are not necessarily two different things. The most effective branding is just an abbreviated version of content.

    Look at the iPhone. The actual selling points of the iPhone are embodied in its very design. You don’t need a long explanation of why the iPhone is desirable, because the selling points are built into it. From a marketing perspective, nothing could be better!

    When you read about the iPhone, you are getting a more in-depth explanation of what is built into the brand.

    Branding and content can be two different expressions of the same thing, so I don’t think it’s a case of one being better. In the end, there is no brand without content — so content is always primary, at least in that sense.

    David Fideler
    Concord Communications and Design

  10. Tim Gonazlez said:

    I seriously love your blog.. Excellent colors & theme. Did you develop this web site yourself? Please reply back as I’m wanting to create my very own website and would like to find out where you got this from or exactly what the theme is called. Thank you!

  11. healthy living said:

    |I am often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your site and keep checking for new information.}

  12. John Steve said:

    Nice one i say nice one

  13. Eric Lemaire said:

    This is very great and brilliant information. Thank you for the valuable information.

  14. instagram online said:

    Thank you so much! This is what I want to learn now instagram technology it’s very helpful. I think both marketing and branding are helpful, but I think branding is more important.

  15. Lofty Converse said:

    Branding is definately becoming more and more important today – Lofty

  16. Lofty Converse said:

    Braning is the way to go in my opinion – Lofty

  17. jennifer Winget said:

    It’s a nice educational article. From this article, we can understand what is the difference between content and Branding. Branding is definitely becoming more and more important today. real estate photo editing companies Thank you for share it with us. It’s an excellent article. I really like it.

  18. john-mac said:

    Are you an iOS fan? Do you want to enjoy the amazements of iOS in your current operating system? Most of the people these days are big fans of iOS. And why not! After all, iOS is fast, powerful, and flawless. However, not everyone can afford to buy expensive iPhones or Apple’s devices.
    visit ios-emulators-for-android

  19. said:

    If you want to get a professional paper written without plagiarism and grammar errors, you can visit the website of the expert services.

  20. Twan Grey said:

    Content and branding are a necessary marketing strategy for any business and its products or services across the internet. The need for professional marketing is increasing exponentially in this competitive world. So many important data regarding the topic can be found in this section. Boost 4g signals in the Netherlands

  21. Ryan B Abraham said:

    It is an informative post, and it gave me some information about the details of content vs branding. Branding is a marketing practice in which a company creates a name, symbol or design that is easily identifiable as belonging to the company. vegan diet You gave a detailed description and easy to understand.

  22. James Stiller said:

    In order to make sure that your essay works out, we recommend that you contact a service online essay writer that will help you with this and as soon as possible will write an essay on any topic and you will definitely stay

  23. George Evans said:

    Chance are small that it will help me, but let’s read first and judge later.

  24. scp096 said:

    Thank you very much for writing such an interesting article on this is a horror free online game

  25. Jaden said:

    One of the main requirements of a good essay is a high level of originality. Be sure that receiving a non-original paper from our service is near to impossible.

  26. ruth gill said: is a popular tech blog where we mainly share news and articles related to internet, Gaming, Discord, Twitch, Minecraft, Windows and other tech troubleshooting help

  27. Pavel said:

    Are you an iOS fan? Do you want to enjoy the amazements of iOS in your current operating system? Most of the people these days are big fans of iOS. And why not! After all, iOS is fast, powerful, and flawless. However, not everyone can afford to buy expensive iPhones or Apple’s devices.
    visit ios-emulators-for-android

  28. masterpaper said:

    Essays are the staple of college paper writing. Each semester, a student spends 50-80 hours writing essays. Feel like there are other – better! – ways to spend time? Then delegate your essays in any subject to our dedicated Mater’s writers.

  29. Corwin said:

    I an assassination attempt by Spain. Over time, pugs have been the favored breed or both royals and celebrities—from Napoleon and Queen Victoria to Andy Warhol and Rob Zombie.

  30. robert said:

  31. emma pk said:

    Content matters. Greetings all here, let me add here that every time you want to announce the launch of any new products or new promotions, it is important to create a yahoo Press release about the event so that you create a buzz. This can be a good way to generate more sales.

  32. Sarah said:

    Keeping a wordle today winning streak alive can be tough. With only six tries to guess the daily answer, your choice of a starting word is key.

  33. seema said:

    One of our fundamental goals is to make sure that our clients can realtor houston tx easily obtain the information they require and can get answers to any queries they could have in this age of information and communications technology

  34. The Citizen said:


  35. Christopher said:

    I found myself nodding along with every word you wrote. Your insights are spot-on! Having recently discovered the Clickspeedtester Click Speed Tester, I was amazed at the benefits it offers. Not only does it help improve your clicking speed and accuracy, but it also serves as a valuable tool for gamers, professionals, and individuals seeking to enhance their hand-eye coordination and reflexes.

  36. eldahehgd said:

    It’s incredible how a single melody classroom 6x or a well-timed crescendo can make us feel the triumph, despair, or exhilaration that the game intends to convey.

  37. PLAY4Doge said:

    PLAY4Doge a good guide for playing with dogecoins

  38. BabyBoxShop said:

    Newborn hamper gifts are special bundles of joy designed to welcome a new addition to the family. These hampers typically contain a combination of baby essentials like clothing, diapers, baby care products, and sometimes sweet treats or keepsakes for the parents to cherish.

  39. iHost VPS said:

    When you decide to buy a VPS in the USA, you gain access to a virtual server hosted within the United States. The USA is known for its robust infrastructure and advanced technology, making it an ideal location for hosting websites, running applications, and conducting online businesses. Buy VPS USA, you can benefit from fast network speeds, low latency, and reliable connectivity, ensuring your online presence is accessible to a wide audience.

  40. iHost VPS said:

    Obtain cheap Windows RDP VPS plans that offer seamless remote access to your Windows environment. Enjoy the combination of affordability and functionality to enhance your workflow and productivity.

  41. Jackson said:

    Building a strong brand is vital because it can create trust and Pokedoku recognition. In situations where people are overwhelmed with choices, a strong brand can provide a sense of security and reliability. Your brand encompasses more than just your logo; it includes your reputation, the quality of your products or services, and the emotions and associations your business evokes.

  42. Carlos said:

    Good blog! Its a great opportunity for that student who wants to learn the English language online. check this if you are looking for film gratis in altadefinizione

  43. iHost VPS said:

    Experience feature-rich virtual server hosting without breaking your budget. Our cheap USA VPS hosting plans provide a reliable and high-performance environment for your websites and applications. Benefit from our cutting-edge infrastructure and USA-based data centres to ensure top-notch performance and accessibility for your online projects.

  44. Tiptop-einrichtung said:

    A friseurstuhl is a specially designed chair that offers comfort and support to clients during a hair salon visit. These chairs are often adjustable in height and have a recline feature for ease of operation.. Explore our collection of stylish and comfortable barber chairs to provide the best experience for your customers.

  45. We Buy Dead Stocks.... said:

    We Buy Dead Stocks is synonymous with trust and reliability for scrap buyers Abu Dhabi. We have a deep understanding of the local market and the expertise to offer competitive prices for your surplus items. Experience a seamless selling process that prioritizes your convenience and ensures you get the best value.

  46. Anrich Thomas said:

    Absolutely! Content plays a crucial role in creating buzz and generating sales. When announcing the launch of new products or promotions, it’s essential to craft a Digital Journal Press release about the event. This will help generate excitement and interest, leading to increased sales and a broader reach for your offerings.

  47. Web3 Newswire said:

  48. Jeff said said:

    Digital Journal Press release

  49. Sabina Holt said:

    Feel free about knowing something new on solar energy, solar power and, of course, solar panel

  50. Bosko said:

    Content marketing is a strategic approach focused on creating and distributing valuable, relevant, and consistent content to attract and retain a clearly defined audience. It aims to drive profitable customer action by offering engaging and informative material rather than overtly promoting a product. Utilizing services like Marketwatch press release
    , Marketwatch press release distribution, and Marketwatch press release service can significantly enhance the reach and impact of content marketing efforts by ensuring that well-crafted press releases gain maximum visibility and credibility among target audiences.

Leave a Reply