Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

Is Writing the Hardest Form of Thinking?

May 8th, 2012 by Bob Bly

In The Writer magazine (6/12, p. 15), my favorite novelist, Pat Conroy (The Prince of Tides, The Great Santini), writes that “Good writing is the hardest form of thinking.”

He continues: “It involves the agony of turning profoundly difficult thoughts into lucid form, then forcing them into the tight-fitting uniform of language, making them visible and clear. If the writing is good, then the result seems effortless and inevitable.”

This sounds nice, but do you buy his claim that good writing is really the hardest form of thinking? I think for most people, the hardest form of thinking is mathematics.

My youngest son is a freshman at Carnegie-Mellon. He took a course in “calculus in three dimensions.” I would wager that calculus in three dimensions is more difficult for most students than English composition.

What do you think?


This entry was posted on Tuesday, May 8th, 2012 at 9:52 am and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

43 responses about “Is Writing the Hardest Form of Thinking?”

  1. Ryan McGrath said:

    Have your son explain “calculus in three dimensions” to you…

    The words he uses are writing.

    The explaining to someone else seems harder to me than just “knowing” the material.

    The guy who wrote the textbook on “calculus in three dimensions” or the professor who wrote the course are performing much harder tasks than the students.

    Or so it seems as think through my point – by writing this note to you. 🙂

  2. Whitney said:

    I was a math major and hated “calculus in three dimensions”. Now, I’m a copywriter.

    Frankly, they’re both the same, except math is difficult because you have to build concept on top of concept. Copywriting is difficult because you have to think of a million things at once for things to turn out right. They both use similar types of creativity/difficulty.

  3. Lesley Peters said:


    at Conroy is my favorite novelist, also. When I read his books, I often read pages or paragraphs aloud because I think his writing is so profound.

    If you compare writing to calculus in 3 dimensions, I would agree the calculus is probably more difficult. However, when you do calculus, do you have to explain it to other people, have it make sense, and be, as Conroy says, “If the writing is good, then the result seems effortless and inevitable?”

    Perhaps it is what we do with the thinking that is of the most consequence.

    Thanks for asking the question. It’s a terrific one to ponder!

    Lesley Peters

  4. Oliver Radini said:

    What an intereesting question…

    It’s rather difficult to compare the two. Both involve handling many ideas at the same time, both involve methods of description that are not entirely idiosyncratic.

    In mathematics it seems there is normally a ‘best practice’ for solving problems, as well prescribed methods of communicating results.

    With writing, there are very few guides. Obviously there is the structure of language, but that is far less defined and universally accepted than most of what you’ll find in maths.

    I think writing is deceptively complex. Because, as Conroy says “If the writing is good, then the result seems effortless and inevitable”.

  5. Ivan Walsh said:

    Writers would like to think so 🙂

  6. Matt Meakins said:

    I think it all depends on how your brain is wired. I was a software engineer but gave it up to be an SEO copywriter because, for me, writing is a vastly more intuitive (and fulfilling) activity than mathematics ever was.

    There’s definitely some overlap, though. I catch myself ‘doing sums’ as I write, in terms of word choice, mixing up sentence lengths, the probability that something will be read versus skimmed, and a zillion other things. But unlike mathematics, much of that number crunching is more or less unconscious.

    I’ve heard that the best mathematicians think in a similar way about numbers – they visualize and intuit concepts much more than they think about the numbers themselves (and we have computers for that anyway, right?)

    Bottom line – both require brains!

  7. Ron Tracy said:

    Sorry everyone but you’ve missed the point – Conroy said “good writing”. Any bimbo can write but good writing is a different matter altogether.

  8. Getresponse email marketing said:

    Getresponse email marketing…

    […]Is Writing the Hardest Form of Thinking? – blog – direct marketing blog[…]…

  9. amourdange said:

    I think it depends on the subject matter.

  10. Kevin Minshaw said:

    I agree with just about everyone’s opinion here. Very good points. I think though that maths is like software development. You can break each process down into steps and, if each component step is correct, and each compound step is correct, then the process is usually correct. So it’s a series of small wins and you can tell if you’re on the right track. Not so much with writing. You never know from each sentence or paragraph you’ve written if what you’ve done is “right”. You just “feel” it is. And that doesn’t mean that your customer or their customer will. So I think writing is a series of small “maybes” and “let’s wait and see” steps. In that sense, it’s almost directionless, except for the loose guidelines of writing. You have to mind read a little. That’s difficult.

  11. Log said:

    hi there! It’s great site. so many topics and opinions. I used to read, basically washingtonpost but now your site one of my favorites. Thank you!

  12. iosman said:

    Love your blog man. Thanks for this stuff.

  13. snap matt said:

    Its feel good when someone writes a good quality content.
    Thanks man for this content..

    snapchat ++

  14. hanuman chalisa said:

    I found very interesting and nice keep sharing awesome shared hanuman chalisa pdf telugu

  15. licidij said:

    Walmart and the Walmart Foundation dramatically increased charitable giving. In 2005, Walmart donated US$20 million in cash and merchandise for Hurricane Katrina relief. Today, walmart credit card login charitable donations approach US$1 billion each year.

  16. said:

    ToxicWap web platform offers a bunch of interesting features that makes it a smart choice among other similar websites

  17. meerab said:

    Thanks, I find your article very informational and i wanna leave here a comment for towing Gulfport

  18. meerab said:

    The facts you’ve got posted could be very beneficial. The websites you’ve got referred become suitable. thank you for mugs

  19. real estate kitchener said:

    A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. combat, law enforcement You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work.

  20. lisa said:

    This is really nice Mindy. So glad that you are continuing to skin and looks like you are encouraging others (JcRabbit for one). Winstep themes is someting sadly missing from Wincustomize. I really look forward to your next skin. Thank you for sharing.real estate kitchener

  21. Arinzona said:

    Writing is the hardest part of thinking.It takes a lot of creativity to write.

  22. techsmithCoupon said:

    I’m excited to uncover this page. I need to to thank you for ones time for this particularly fantastic read !! I definitely really liked every part of it and i also have you saved to fav to look at new information in your site.

  23. port stanley real estate said:

    A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing us.

  24. Susan Hais said:

    I like the way you made this article. Short but interesting.Thanks for sharing!

  25. personalized kids mugs said:

    Oh my goodness! a tremendous article dude. Thank you Nonetheless I’m experiencing difficulty with ur rss . Don know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anybody getting equivalent rss problem? Anybody who is aware of kindly respond. Thnkx

  26. Susan Hais said:

    Thank you for sharing such a nice post.
    Keep it up!

  27. iot development said:

    Since this was first published, the zip files have been missing a copy of AButton.spin (a simple button polling object) which is used by the GOLDEtest.spin demo program. The file now contains AButton.spin as it should have. Since this was first published, the zip files have been missing a copy of AButton.spin (a simple button polling object) which is used by the GOLDEtest.spin demo program. The file now contains AButton.spin as it should have.

  28. iot development said:

    Microsoft Office Setup is the full package of Microsoft limitation programming which joins a mix of employments, affiliations, and host like Excel, PowerPoint, Word, OneNote, Publisher and Access. Close by the working frameworks, these jobs are Microsoft’s key things that are everything seen as utilized programming on Earth. Microsoft Office Setup bundles all the very best programming which Microsoft moves on to the table.

  29. Susan Hais said:

    Nice Article, Thanks for share this.

  30. Flat fee said:

    I would agree with your post. It’s difficult to write the 1200 words needed for my Real Estate posts. Although when done it’s very rewarding.
    Thanks. Great article

  31. sailboat charter bvi said:

    Miniature Load Cells

    This particular papers astounding, and My spouse and that i enjoy every of the take impact which you have placed into this. Im firm that you’ll be making a in truth useful area. I has been moreover deferential. exact play-success

  32. san diego landmarks said:

    Karena kita telah memahami masing-masing dari berbagai sifat yang saling bertentangan, terutama permainan poker online terbaik

  33. said:

    Our team is working with you for the academic discipline that you face troubles in. Assignment is a hard task for the stuents so that is not possible for the student to complete it accurately. So the online helpers at is keeps offering its excellent Biology Assignment Help services and make their academic life easy.

  34. Polarised safety glasses said:

    Hello, Karena kita telah memahami masing-masing dari berbagai sifat yang saling bertentangan, terutama permainan poker online terbaik.

  35. site said:

    Don’t know the difference between your beam type and pre-set torques? Read this blog to find out some handy tips for repairing your bike and save some money!site

  36. Rinella Prosthetics said:

    Truly, this article is really one of the best in the history of articles. I am an ancient ‘Article’ collector and I sometimes read some new articles if I find them interesting. And I found this one pretty fascinating and it should go to my collection. Very good work!

  37. Rinella Prosthetics said:

    I am speechless. This is a superb weblog and very engaging too. Nice work! That’s now not actually so much coming from an newbie publisher like me, but it’s all I could say after diving into your posts. Nice grammar and vocabulary.No longer like other blogs.You in point of fact realize what you?re talking approximately too. Such a lot that you simply made me want to discover more. Your blog has develop into a stepping stone for me, my friend.

  38. helium 10 amazon said:

    helium 10 fba tool is SEO and product research software. It has been mainly designed for Amazon sellers. This product is said to have several features

  39. brazilian butt lift before and after said:

    simply I experience your web page furthermore practising and beneficial opinion. it is protected enormously handy calculation as soon as a variety of our assets.thanks for element. i enjoy this make acknowledged.

  40. grammarly trial said:

    2019 grammarly discount on trial is my Grammarly dashboard. As you can see, it is not flooded with tons of buttons and links. You get only what you want.

  41. small scale lng plant said:

    Royalqq merupakan salah satu situs poker rekomendasi dari daftarqq21 untuk anda mainkan melalui royalqq

  42. lisa said:

    Can I say what relief to find someone who really knows what theyre discussing on the net. You definitely have learned to bring a difficulty to light making it important. The diet should look at this and understand why side on the story. I cant believe youre less common simply because you definitely possess the gift.natural spray deodorant

  43. lisa said:

    Download Antivirus App Help protect your phone and tablet from harmful viruses, malware, spyware, scamware and text messages and keep your personal data safe with an app lock and picture vault.Mallorca

Leave a Reply