Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

Why you should NOT clean your elist

July 17th, 2018 by Bob Bly

The conventional wisdom has long been to zap people from your
email list if they have not responded to any of your offers
within the last 6 months — and especially if they have not opened
any of your emails within that time.

But now, a new study from MailChimp suggests you should not.

The reason?

MailChimp found that inactive subscribers, contrary to what many
believe, are far from worthless.

The MailChimp study shows that just because an online subscriber
is inactive does not mean he will remain so.

In fact, many inactive subscribers eventually buy again — even
after a year or several years of taking no action.

MailChimp says that, on average, about one-third of online
revenues from your elist will come from inactive subscribers — so
clearly they have real value.

Because keeping the inactives on your list is relatively cheap,
and inactives are 26% more likely to purchase than
non-subscribers, to me it makes good sense to leave people on
your list until they opt out.

Many of my readers have confirmed with me the value of inactive
names on their list.

BS says: “Yes, we just had one of our leads who ignored all of
our emails and phone calls for 7 months buy a product from us

JH comments: “Dean Jackson is as good as it gets with email. He
recently said the people who convert to some of his highest level
stuff have been on his list for 2 years.”

SB: “I convert customers who’ve been on my lists for 1,2,3,4
years later. This purge thing was partly started by the advice of
not sending to unopens.”

JL: “If someone raises their hand in terms of going to a workshop
or seeing me, we keep them on our newsletter until they cry uncle
or die. We get at least a few new clients a year that have been
on that list for years. There is gold in unconverted leads.”

KD: “I had one guy order a product, then two weeks later bought
another product. Week after that bought another. So I checked him
out. He’d been on my list for years but never bought before.”

AR: “I’ve had email subscribers who tune out for months at a
time… and then suddenly hire me or buy stuff I recommend.”

The major argument in favor of purging inactives is that having a
lot of them on your list hurts your email delivery rate.

Well, yes and no. There are two types of services providing email
delivery. The first includes vendors such as Constant Contact and
Bronto, where the bigger your list, the more they charge you.

These email service providers make more money from clients with
large lists. So they have no incentive to penalize you for having
a big list. And as far as I know, they do not.

The other category is services that give you an unlimited number
of email distributions for a fixed monthly cost, such as

Since it costs them money to distribute … and earns them no extra
money to email to large lists … they have a motive for actively
encouraging you to drop inactive subscribers from your list, and
some of them do so.

That being said, I agree with JL: In my experience, there is gold
in unconverted leads. And I am really not into throwing gold in
the trash (or delete folder).

The other argument in favor of purging inactive subscriber names
is that their non-responsiveness brings down your key metrics
including click-through rate and open rate. JA comments, “If your
open rate is below benchmark despite having consistently good
content, there’s probably some dead weight in your list.”

However, low CTR and open rates are a problem mainly if you have
a boss or client judging you by those numbers.

But if you are an entrepreneur with your own internet marketing
business, the most important key metric to use is weekly gross

And as MailChimp and others quoted above note, continuing to
email to your inactives can boost what is arguably the most
important key performance indicator — revenue — substantially.

So what’s more important to you — good-looking analytics reports
… or money in your bank account?

It’s your call.


This entry was posted on Tuesday, July 17th, 2018 at 11:43 am and is filed under Online Marketing. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

34 responses about “Why you should NOT clean your elist”

  1. Glenn Clayton said:

    Great piece thanks for sharing this. I find it to be really educative. amazon floor lamps

  2. Gavin Hancock said:

    By visiting this site I found cool stuff here keep it up. driver toolkit key 2018

  3. Rabecca Johnson said:

    This is good ….. it will surely helps me and others
    Keep Posting
    Mail Problems

  4. Franklin said:

    The information is really very helpful for me. Thanks for the update for more visit Geek Squad Support

  5. september blank calendar 2018 said:

    online marketing best platform

  6. Game Killer App Download said:

    Game Killer App Download

  7. Bradford wilson said:

    Are you struggling with some kind of issue related to yahoo ??
    How To Fix Can’t Sign Into Yahoo Mail | Yahoo Mail Sign In Problems

  8. Surya Prakash said:

    TutuApp APK Download gives you access to boundless applications and TutuApp Vip Free diversions without having to escape your gadget, which guards your gadget while downloading (TutuApp free download) any product through it as its center security framework isn’t exasperates.

  9. said:

    Old Navy is an American clothing and accessories retailing company owned by American multinational corporation Gap Inc. |
    oldnavy feedback

  10. wps connect said:

    download the application and connect to all private networks

  11. hide man said:

    Credit or Debit card offers users numbers of benefits.
    Mainly card makes purchases and payments
    a lot easier than you ever had imagined. Cashback, rewards, free gifts, credit points
    also are offered on using the cards.

    capitalone com activate platinum mastercard platinum

    capital one activate debit card

  12. krogerfeedback said:

    Kroger Feedback: It is an American retailing company and United States’
    largest supermarket chain and the second-largest general retailer and
    the twenty-third largest company in the United States.
    It was founded in 1883 with just $400, and its headquarter
    is on the Vine Street in downtown Cincinnati.
    It is supervised by Mr. W. Rodney McMullen
    and his right-hand man Mr. Michael L. Ellis

    Kroger Feedback Customer Satisfaction Survey –

  13. latestinfo said:


  14. Katieaylor said:

    What a great information you shared with us, I am inspired by the method for the stage. It kept joined me regularly. Keep doing awesome. Thanks for sharing this blog article.

  15. Woof said:

  16. my surveys said:

    There is an online RaceTrac Survey performance managed on its official gateway
    at TellRaceTrac survey. Racetrac customers are required to join this Racetrac Survey and share
    their authentic and accurate feedback as per their own visit experience at their official website By this survey, the company wants to know about the customer’s
    feedback, complaints, suggestions, reviews etc. RaceTrac Survey offering their customers to Win
    the Free Racetrac Coupon code for free food at Racetrac Retail Store. application

    racetrack survey

    racetrac validation code

  17. hj said:

    Hi Friends. today below on our website and in this article we are going to talk about the my as you all are waiting for the

    Dollar General Customer Satisfaction Survey

  18. my-surveys said:

    Hey, there is a chance to get gain Free Route 44 Drink you just need to complete the simple exercise.
    To get free drinks User just needs to join TALK TO SONIC SURVEY. So if you interested in this amazing offer
    you need to get aware of Survey first. Don’t worry we are here to help you, we will
    take you throughout the whole process and also share requirement that you need to enter Sonic Customer Satisfaction Survey.
    We suggest our readers to walkthrough from this post which gives you all the information that you need to
    complete Sonic Customer Feedback Survey successfully.

  19. nikol said:

    What a great information you shared with us, I am inspired by the method for the stage. It kept joined me regularly. Keep doing awesome. Thanks for sharing this blog article

  20. locat mark said:

    Welcome to our official site. KFC is World’s most popular fast-food chain. It serves numbers of delicious, tasty, and spicy item’s to millions of customers throughout the world. It is world famous for serving spicy chicken dishes, french fries, and coke to the foodies.

  21. latestinfo said:


  22. No Bake Recepie said:

    Dgcustomerfirst here you can win up to $1000 by taking Dgcustomerfirst survey and also kohlslistens provide you chance to get free money,prizes and get ready and take the survey

  23. Wood said:

    McDonald’s is one of the Franchises of USA. McDonald’s is an American fast food Company, founded in 1940 as a Restaurant operated by Richard and Maurice McDonald, in San Bernardino, California, United States. It is most Popular in the World.

  24. hide man said:

    Credit or Debit card offers users numbers of benefits.
    Mainly card makes purchases and payments
    a lot easier than you ever had imagined. Cashback, rewards, free gifts, credit points
    also are offered on using the cards.

    capitalone com activate platinum mastercard

  25. Wooc said:

    You can win a reward and gift card for complete Mooyah Survey. Nowadays almost every brand and company want to know their customer feedback to improve their product and services and this is possible only when real people and their customer give feedback about their services and product.

  26. rabola said:

    I seriouly don’t understand why you guy’s are dragging this much when it comes to delivering the fantastic content. I hope ill get good results when i search from next time from a Football follower(

  27. jully said:

    I wonder if you have visited any store, restaurant or supermarkets,
    How about if you share your experience of the products and services.
    The company wants to know from you about your genuine experience and
    takes the review from you through their survey programs

    Jack in the Box Survey

    Jack in the Box customer satisfaction survey

    Jack in the Box survey online

  28. hinarai said:

    Murphy USA survey, They are discussing the customers experience and how the customers are filled at their gas station.

  29. locat mark said:

    Welcome to official site:

  30. discover card logon said:

    for more click here

  31. Rajajirajput said:

    How to the best game download Tank Trouble Unblocked

  32. Eva Green said:

    Pretty Teddybear ! This has been an extremely wonderful article. Thank you for providing this information.Earth Fare

  33. Smart Surveys said:

    Very good article. I really like this website. Thank you!Europcar Boots Opticians

  34. Sig said:

    Great post, It really help me a lot, tks

Leave a Reply