Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

More of this + less of that = success

September 15th, 2017 by Bob Bly

As noted in an earlier issue of this newsletter, I believe that
today many people — and in particular, many younger people — are
fascinated with bright, shiny objects (BSOs).

By “BSO,” I mean they embrace the new, trendy, hip, and cool …
and as a corollary, eschew the old, the proven, and the tried and

This favoring of BSOs over tested methods and ideas is true in
many fields, but especially so in marketing.

I contend that doing so is an egregious error.


Two reasons.

First, to paraphrase George Santayana — “Those who forget the
past, don’t learn from it.”

Or more to the point, as Martin Cohen writes in his book Reason
and Nature:

“The notion that we can dismiss the views of all previous
thinkers surely leaves no basis for the hope that our own work
will prove of any value to others.”

To me this is “axiomatic,” which means it is irrefutable logic
and always true.

Think about it: if you dismiss the views of all who came before
you, then shouldn’t the next generation conclude they can learn
nothing from you?

Second, the problem with BSOs is: they are untested and unproven.

That makes them highly risky and more likely to fail.

By comparison, the tried and true is tested and proven.

That reduces your risk of a big failure … and increases the odds
of success.

How does this translate into direct marketing?

Well, many times I have come up with an initial selling idea for
a product.

When I run it past the client, they say — “That won’t work; we
know because we have tested it many times, and in each test it
always failed.”

A BSO fan would argue:

“Well, just because you guys couldn’t get it to work doesn’t mean
it won’t work now. Get some cojones and try it my way!”

Not me. As an old-school direct response guy, I am grateful the
client knows the idea has been tested and proven ineffective, as
it saves me from writing something that will more than likely

I thank them, go back to the drawing board, and brainstorm, both
on my own and often with them, to find a new idea with the
potential to be a winner.

Other old-time direct response copywriters tell me they agree
that the surest and most likely route to a winner is to take what
is tested and proven, dust it off, and give it a new twist.

As my old friend, superstar copywriter Richard Armstrong, wrote
in an article for AWAI:

“I believe there’s a much better word than creativity to describe
what we’re really striving for in this business: Ingenuity.

“What you really want to do is study what’s worked in the past.
Find out what’s working now. And see if you can come up with a
way to do the exact same thing … only better.

“If you do that, I guarantee you catch more customers … and
eventually more clients, too!”

In copywriting, it is rare to find something under the sun that
is entirely new.

More often, winning comes from saying the same old thing, but
saying it in a fresh and compelling new way.

And then test, test, test.

Don’t assume your idea, whether old school or BSO, is the best.

You don’t know. You have to test.

In marketing, as the great Claude Hopkins wrote: The only way to
settle the question of whether an ad will work is with a test,
not with arguments around a table.

And then, once we direct marketers roll it out, while continually
testing to beat our control.

Back in my day, people at Madison Avenue ad agencies hated the
tested direct response control.

They believed in their intuition and subjective judgment of their
peers: If everyone at the agency or my friends in advertising
think my ad is clever, funny, or creative, it must be good!

This in part explains the gross ineffectiveness of so many widely
admired national ad campaigns for major brands produced by the
big ad agencies.

My friend, motivational Rob Gilbert, says the key to success in
virtually every walk of life is:

“Do more of what works, and less of what doesn’t work.”

Pretty simple. Common sense. And good advice.


This entry was posted on Friday, September 15th, 2017 at 12:25 pm and is filed under General, Success. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

16 responses about “More of this + less of that = success”

  1. Akemi said:

    Once I read the article of the writer who write my paper for me on success and convenience of marriage. Of course, it could go the other way around, couldn’t it, and still come up with the same results. Financial strain puts pressure on marriages and the relationships within a family, causing instability, causing tension within the home, causing kids to have difficulties and less long term success. I have not read the study, so maybe the authors have controlled for such ideas, but it does seem like a study in which 100 different factors could be, together, responsible for the results and the authors of the study and the writer here have focused on the factor and the hypothesis they wanted to support.

    That being said, the more people kids have who love them and support them and give them good advice the better. Whether within a legally registered family or not. Life is hard. We all have to help each other through.

  2. Marry said:

    Back in my day, people at Madison Avenue ad agencies hated the tested direct response control.
    happy wheels online.

  3. Nishant Gaurav said:

    Wonderful way to deal

  4. Shawn said:

    It is true that there is no point in working more on what doesn’t work for you. It will only waste your time and literally offers you nothing. Meanwhile, invest that time in what works for you and enjoys its results.
    wood spindles

  5. lsdkfjlsfjk said:

    Don’t worry about your old property Hasan Ali Zaidi help you to sell your former estate. And if you have to buy a property then Hasan Ali Zaidi show you the best option.

  6. AlanSmith said:

    Marketing is the best one to promote anything. According to the best essay writing services, most of the people are finding many ways to promote the products. People always looking for the unique ideas and getting attracted to the ads.

  7. Isabella said:

    well this formula are for the ones who are special enough to understand it, I order an assignment to understand this formula of success, I came to conclusion that you need to be determined no matter what happens.

  8. Joseph S. Nabors said:

    There is no confidence in the weather in India, and there is always rain, and whenever the fast air, come then if there is a car in your house, the car went dirty, and you still have to clean your car. But here a simple way to handle this best car vacuum cleaner and reduce your tension.

  9. William riley said:

    Do not bother with completing an essay at the eleventh hour; you know you won’t be able to do it. Just get a Best Essay Writer for us to do your project for you instead, and ensure that it is finished in time.

  10. matthewwade said:

    Advertising is the best Coursework Writers one to advance anything. As per the ssss the vast majority of the general population are finding numerous approaches to advance the items. Individuals continually searching for the one of a kind thoughts and getting pulled in to the advertisements.

  11. panistefanin said:

    Thank you for your work on the blog! You’re doing a good job! Thanks for the useful information! You helped me with advice!

    wells fargo routing number 

  12. STELLA BAN said:

    I came to the conclusion which you want to be decided no matter what happens. in the meantime, make investments that time in what works for you and enjoys its effects. Essay Writer A remarkable way to deal.

  13. nissa said:

    The formula here shared is really correct and it is enough to understand it.This is the quote of most of the success persons they agreed on it.I’m happy to read this article and continue sharing more informative what he said

  14. puvuvob said:

    The feedback received from the customers will be observed by the management and the necessary changes will be made to provide the target survey better shopping experience to their customers.

  15. ritariya said:

    To promote business marketing is the good thing. The products should be ideal and fresh. Good products should be sold. They should have proper idea about the business and the product. They should be well firm in selling the product.private day tours amsterdam

  16. GeekSquad said:

    Now don’t worry when you stuck in a problem we provide you best expert customer service through GeekSquadUs

Leave a Reply