Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

The awful truth about cold calling

February 12th, 2014 by Bob Bly

Is cold calling to get new copywriting clients a good, bad, or
terrible idea?

EF writes:

“I did have a question that I thought you might be able to
answer. I’ve been receiving a lot of mail attempting to sell me
credit cards from big names like Discover, Capital One, and

“But I’ve noticed the writing is rather poor–it’s a statement
of features, sometimes of benefits, but with no real attempt at
persuasion. I’ve done some brainstorming and believe I could
rewrite these in such a way as to increase sales for these

“My thought was to try cold-calling/emailing these companies and
attempting to sell them on my idea of rewriting for greater
persuasion. So I was wondering if you had any advice, ideas, or
tips on the best way to go about this–or even if it’s a
worthwhile idea!”

My bad news for EF is: cold calling to get copywriting clients
is a terrible idea – probably the worst way to go about looking
for copywriting clients ever devised.

There are 5 reasons why I urge freelance copywriters to avoid
cold calling at all costs.

1-Clients want to work with vendors whom they perceive as busy
and successful. By logical extension, if you have nothing better
to do than sit at your desk dialing the phone and asking
strangers to hire you, clients conclude you are not busy,
successful, or in demand. So right away you cause the prospect
to be repulsed by your seeming desperation rather than to be
attracted to you and your services.

2-When you quote your fee, the client whom you find through
cold calling will almost always try to beat you down. Why?
Because they know you need the work. Otherwise, why would you
have called them? Cold calling destroys your leverage.

3-If you tell them you are calling because you have received
their marketing campaigns and believe them to be ineffective,
you risk making a fool of yourself, because the marketing you
say stinks may in fact be working like gangbusters. You don’t

4-Another problem with telling potential clients their copy
stinks is that the person you are speaking with may be
responsible for it and not agree with you. So you start off the
relationship by arguing with and insulting her. Is that smart?

5-Cold calling is a form of telemarketing, a marketing
technique that has slowly fallen out of favor over the years
because it is overly intrusive and interruptive. Lots of people
hate telemarketers, so for you to become one does not position
you favorably with your potential clients.

The bottom line: cold calling is a bad idea because it violates
the Silver Rule of Marketing, formulated by my colleague Pete
Silver, who says: “It is always better to get them to come to
you than for you go to them.”


This entry was posted on Wednesday, February 12th, 2014 at 10:14 am and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

35 responses about “The awful truth about cold calling”

  1. Chris said:

    A lot of people and copywriters recommend cold calling–Tim Ferriss, you in your book Secrets of a Freelance Writer–as a way to drum up potential leads. That you tear apart cold calling in this post as a complete waste of time that is sure to hurt your prospect of landing decent paying work is pretty surprising.

  2. Fred Venapro said:

    The last part of your post was spot on cold calling is a bad idea because it is always better to get them to come to you than for you go to them.

    This is why we use the internet.

  3. SEO and content writing tips: Week ending Feb. 18, 2014 » SEO Copywriting said:

    […] Bly writes The awful truth about cold calling on his […]

  4. Robert said:

    I agree completely with his premise. As someone who has made a living out of cold-calling, I have seen the response that it generates falling quite dramatically. In the early 90’s it was possible to make 4-5 good appointments a day in almost all B2B environments. Those days have gone for good. What’s required now is good lead-generation copywriting to encourage prospects to come to you.

  5. William Reynolds said:

    My biggest single mistake in the first year of my freelance copywriting career was the time wasted on cold-calling (and cold-emailing, which amounts to the same thing). By contrast, the smartest moves I made in that first year were (1) to put the phone down and start doing some serious in-person networking, and (2) to start asking satisfied clients for referrals and introductions. It’s about relationships, not “touches.”

  6. Bob Bly said:

    Chris, Robert: I stand 100% by my post.Cold calling puts you in a weak position. When they come to you, you are in command. Example: Someone called me a day or say ago needing copy. I was referred to him by a person he respects — so much so that within 10 minutes of chatting he paid me a $12,000 advance for copy. Try matching that on a cold call.

  7. Don Wallace said:

    Bob, I got into a food fight on WarriorForum for debating your point about cold calling. That some people regard you as an infallible hero is great (hell, I’d love that myself), but some questions still remain.

    – You DID write positively about cold calling/telemarketing years ago. So exactly what changed?

    – Yes, it would be wonderful to have the fat contracts walk through the door or come in the in-box. But for those of us who are not widely published as you are with personal references from the likes of David Ogilvy, that’s just not happening. Your anecdote simply doesn’t play out for anyone unless they have laid groundwork of massive credibility. Or… am I missing something?

    – You just pushed out a mailing that indicates that social media (Facebook, at least) is a waste of time with poor payoff. (That, I couldn’t agree with more.)

    – You have also indicated in some recent articles that content marketing is overhyped as well. (I also agree here.)

    It appears that you have debunked many avenues of self marketing that conventional wisdom points to. What’s left? To generate new billable business, what do you recommend now?

  8. hollister said:

    Calling Herpes one the the scariest STD is really an over statement. Did you know that HIV is actually in the top of the list by far, as it has not yet a cure for it. Also almost 30% of people infected with HIV don know they have it, because they simply don get tested.. They blank you. A punter in a club said to me once,hollister clothing, You’re just a doorman. You’ll never be anything else. Alan, the president of Bayside Investments, Inc., and Colin, Bayside’s accountant, are charged with a cr

  9. Julie said:


    What is your take on warm emailing a prospect that you have identified to be a good fit for your services?

  10. Mike Rolsy said:

    I saw a lot of website but I conceive this one holds something special in it in it. Look on this site where you can see a lot of interesting things: rosetta stone activation code generator

  11. said:

  12. james bruce said:

    nice post

  13. Paisley22 said:

    Potbelly Survey gives you Free Sandwich Coupon Code. Just participate in the Potbelly Listens survey and complete it successfully. Read the rules and follow …

  14. enishji said:

    Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana Form, Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana Benefits, Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana Account/

  15. simran212 said:

    ???????????? ???? ??????? ???? ?? 22-09-2018 ?? ????????? (?????) ??? ?? ?? ???? ????? ?? ??????? ????? Saksham Yojna Applicant Detail

  16. manjila said:

    PMGDISHA Details In Hindi, PMGDISHA Download Certificate/ Saksham Yojna Applicant Detail

  17. Jennifer Winget said:

    I have gone through this article named’ The awful truth about cold calling’. The first time I read this article so I am very happy to read it. importance of information technology And the way of writing is really nice. Thank you.

  18. Justin Jacob said:

    Thanks for sharing such a useful piece of information. After reading your post I thought of freelance copywriters. You are right they are calling us for hiring them. That means they don’t have enough work to do, so they need us to give them work. private tours paris The reasons you shared are very clear.

  19. qmbqwerv said:

    Nike UK Consumer Feedback Survey website

    Mothercare Feedback Survey

  20. ryanbabraham said:

    Awesome article. Thanks for sharing such a useful piece of information. I don’t have any idea about it. This post gives a proper idea about copywriting. After reading your post I thought of freelance copywriters. Please share this kind of information. Iphone external antenna Waiting for more updates.

  21. Sanshilakl said:

    Accessible India Campaign

  22. Piniroy said:

    BJ’s Wholesale Club Customer Survey BJ’s Wholesale Club Customer Survey

  23. Fanigafa said:

    Lastly, submit your review for your chance to win. Turbo Prepaid Card Activate

  24. Uaersjfhkpoi said:

    The company needs to transform you into an unwavering client forever.

  25. Fushikavali said:

    CVS is asking for Satisfaction in regards to purchases made in-store from their valuable customers

  26. Ershinakj said:

    Rush Card Activation

  27. Qoriyaserfl said:

    First, you have to visit the mychart henry ford login page
    Now the mychart henry ford login portal required a valid username

  28. Andardekar said:

    Just received your new TD Bank credit card, debit card, Visa card,

  29. Ragilashahi said:

    Apply for Loan Online If you are looking for Loan online or Want to Get Quick Loan

  30. Benn Vincent said:

    Working from needs a fast and stable mobile connection but the unfortunate reality is that it is true. But, there is a solution called mobile phone signal booster

  31. vifowasds said:

  32. One Dasty said:

    Bringingy is a wonderful experience involving the whole family, which is why we begin training early to ease the transition to their new home and family. Owning a pug puppy or French Bulldog puppy is hard work. Making sure they are raised and trained properly can be overwhelming at first, but by offering our customers a great amount of support, we assist in the preparations to make it less stressful. To provide a completely different environment for our puppies, we thoroughly researched and make sure this puppies will only go to respectable families

  33. McOrlando said:

    All of and puppy, health certificate, genetic guarantee, and AKC registration papers. All new families are required to sign a contract that includes a basic health guarantee and a 3 year genetic health guarantee. They have been raised in our home around small children, kittens and dogs of every size to help them develop well round personalities accustomed to daily home activates. We encourage families to ask question and to stay in contact with us.
    All puppies sold as pets will go home spayed-neutered! We also sell puppies along with breeding right. Note this will include an additional fee.

  34. Kristen said:

    Nice blog post. Keep posting. For more infor check here..

  35. robert said:

Leave a Reply