Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

The awful truth about online reviews

May 9th, 2017 by Bob Bly

Anybody who is in the public eye on the internet … even someone
as minor as me … will invariably get his fair share of people who
feel compelled to bash him — often in a nasty and mean-spirited

Of course the conventional wisdom is to shrug it off. But I
sometimes find it difficult not to take personally.

For instance, MM writes:

“I have purchased several of Bob’s products on his websites and
found them to be a complete rip-off. He charges $50 for 80 pages
of useless, outdated content.”

It’s easy for me to prove that MM is by far a minority opinion;
take a look at some of the testimonials from my e-newsletter,
book, and e-book readers:

Also, most of my e-books are in the $29 to $39 range, not $50
(though a few are).

MM’s comment proves to me something I read in an article in a PC
magazine more than a decade ago:

“The best thing about the Internet is that anyone can post
anything to it.

“The worst thing about the Internet is that anyone can post
anything to it.”

Evidence of the latter statement is in an article on Quora
reporting a Harvard study concluding that one out of five reviews
on Yelp are fake.

And on one occasion, a reviewer gave my new book a one-star
review saying I hadn’t been polite to him when he asked me a
question online; he had not even read the book.

Amazon says reviews cannot be personal vendettas and have to be
based on the book itself.

And though I have notified them 3 times that this particular
review is based on a personal incident, Amazon has ignored my
repeated requests to have it removed on that basis.

Also, back in the day, book reviews were written by professional
book reviewers who often had a background and knowledge in the
topic of the book.

And their reviews were vetted by a newspaper or magazine editor
prior to publication.

Now online reviews on Amazon and elsewhere are written by any
Tom, Dick, and Harry with a computer and an internet connection.
They are not required to have a working knowledge of the topic of
the book … and no editor is there to make sure the reviews are
civil, literate, and accurate.

Which do you prefer — book reviews by professional reviewers, as
in the New York Times Book Review or the New York Review of Books
(the latter is my favorite periodical)?

Or the opinions of consumers, which range from honest and smart
to pure Bozo?


This entry was posted on Tuesday, May 9th, 2017 at 12:11 pm and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

93 responses about “The awful truth about online reviews”

  1. impact lifting said:

    Você já se sente incomodada com as rugas e flacidez, se sente envergonhada, não gosta de sair para festas, eventos, ou mesmo aquele momento especial no final de semana junto aos amigos, pois sempre foi muito coquete e essas primeiras marcas do tempo, talvez marcas de uma vida que não foi fácil, já estão te incomodando muito.
    Pensado Para Você
    Pensando em você Organic Peel, uma associação respeitada por seus métodos naturais e veganos(sem origem animal) na produção de benefícios para beleza.
    Ideais para mulheres que querem assim como você aumentar a auto-estima e o bem estar.Agora a Organic Peel inova outra vez trazendo o Impact Lift, produto que já é sucesso por exemplo com a assistente do programa Do Ratinho Milene Pavorô.
    Mas, calma estamos só começando a apresentar o Impact Lift para você, e não pense que é um produto super caro, usado apenas por celebridades.
    Ele foi pensado para você, para mudar a sua vida.

  2. Ashwin said:

    Everyone should Must needed to visit the homepage of Fire Boy and Water Girl website play online free fireboy and watergirl and play the extra ordinary Mind twister video game for free.You can play this game online with your friends also by inviting them.

  3. Aboughtters said:

    You are getting all the expertise of present card equilibrium on this account. You need to go into 16th figure number to obtain go into in your control panel.

  4. Kartika said:

    Facing a problem while a user want to enable bluetooth in window 10 , you may finish this error from this website ,this is fabulous website.

  5. Alisa said:

    I think this is a really good article. You make this information interesting and engaging. circloo 2 cool math

  6. NinDa said:

    Your blog is really a good platform to get informative posts. It is really a helpful platform. awesome tanks 2 cool math

  7. selfie said:

    Engineering as a subject combines mathematics, logic and science to find solutions to our daily life problems. Over the last few decades, engineering as a profession has seen vast expansion.
    B Tech college in punjab
    Online admission cgc
    Private management college in punjab
    agriculture College in mohali

  8. Mellissa Turner said:

    Choosing Wm1 app has helped me to stay in touch with the Walmart management, whenever required. Wm1 app

  9. eric mer said:

    I agree that most reviews are fake. I have close friends that manage a restaurant on Tripadvisor, and most of the reviews have been purchased. He is honest about it. Prepaidgiftbalance Mygiftcardsite
    our sainsbury Oursainsburys
    Tesco payslipview Payslipview

  10. Ricky O'kefee said:

    Fifa 19 Luckiest packs offer.
    Just Click the link below and follow steps;

  11. pranav said:

    keep sharing this types of valueable article.

  12. EViews 10 Download said:

    amazing post Surely inspired many people
    EViews is a statistical package for Windows, mainly used for analyzing the time-based economy. This quantity is now developed by Microsoft Microsoft, which is now part of the IHS. Version 1.0 was released in March 1994 and replaced Micro TSP.
    Evidence can be used for general data analysis and standard analysis, such as cross-section and panel data analysis and time series estimation and predictions.
    clcik here for more

  13. Gos said:

    The Health system is created in a proficient way of expanding the network in the multispecialty services. With the ever-growing population, the hospital has announced many ambitious plans that have ultimately lead to the excellence.
    maternity Hospital in hisar
    best IVF center in hisar
    laparoscopy surgery in hisar
    best play school in hisar

  14. Ricky O'kefee said:

    Liteblue is USPS’s associate platform, used to check schedules, paychecks, benefits and more by all United States Postal Service personnel.
    Get the ultimate guide;

  15. VIolette Tillman said:

    We’re a website that wants to give detailed buying guides to wine cooler and wine fridges and this will become a wine cooler buying guide we will publish in our blog.
    Here it is;
    You will surely like it.

  16. Ricky O'kefee said:

    As you are searching shower water filter that removes Flouride and Improves your Skin and Hair then one product is rotting in my head and that is STK Premium Shower Filter.
    Purchase it without any hesitation.
    Here it is;

  17. amazing said:

    thx for sharing this. keyboard-shortcuts-alt

  18. Prasanta sarkar said:

    Wow amazing, thanks for share this
    visit bengali news in west bengal india!


    i will must try this..Thank you for sharing such a wonderful information about this. You can also view more about Private Limited Company Registration:

  20. Piyush said:

    Private limited organization enlistment requires some lawful advances and attentive procedures. To finish the procedure of online organization development, you have to think about what is a private constrained organization, how to frame private restricted organization, required archives for an organization arrangement, advantages of private constrained organization arrangement, and so on.
    Private Limited Company Registration

  21. Camila said:

    “The best thing about the Internet is that anyone can post
    anything to it.” Well said…

    cheap fifa 20 coins
    I love FIFA Coins. 🙂

  22. Rajesh Kumar said:

    Melbourne Airport Transfers

  23. Krishna Singh said:

    Data Entry Projects

  24. John Mcqeen said:

    The truth can not be declined that now a days people are doing what they like to do on the internet. So they review anything anytime and with any perceptive as well. So I can imagine the situation you are feeling.

    My website is about American Express credit card and i know how to review something in a great way.
    John Mcqeen

  25. Biomiracle Beauty product said:

    Thank you sharing for great information. Biomiracle is best organic skin care products in India. Our products will helps in moisturizing, lifting and revitalizes your skin from pimples, anti-aging wrinkles and dark circles. organic moisturizing face mask

  26. 8th Class Result 2020 said:

    It is need of assessment to check through the whole blog approach in best mode8th Class Result 2020

  27. Kevin said:

    Lawyers in Melbourne

  28. David said:

    Family and Divorce Lawyer

  29. Ben Wills said:

    I ma also a reviewer but my method of review is so different.
    Ben Wills

  30. prasanta said:

    i will must try this..Thank you for sharing such a wonderful information about this. You can also view:UBG NEWS

  31. Nlite said:

    Good blog nice to see this blog thank you sharing us. Nlite is a leading digital marketing agency that focuses on growing your business successfully with online marketing services.we have the right technologies like email marketing tools, analytics, SEO, and performance measurement techniques that will show you how exactly your campaign is working with regular updates from our team. digital media marketing services

  32. Barry Richards said:

    will must try this..Thank you for sharing such a wonderful information about this. You can also view:

  33. Epayslip said:

    visit the official portal for IRIS Open Payslip employee payroll login, registration & password recovery details. The IRIS open payslip UK acts as a medium in between the employers and employees.

  34. ajinkya said:

    Hey now you can download paid apps for free using the golden cydia. Download the golden cydia store from this site.

  35. batono said:

    This is the guide for affirming any of the AMEX charge cards. So on the off chance that you are as yet befuddled about it, don’t hesitate to get some information about AMEX. Or on the other hand you can essentially go to and actuate your AMEX card without any problem

  36. shubham said:

    “The best thing about the Internet is that anyone can post
    anything to it.” NICE

  37. Fishkin James said:

    My Americans find it difficult to confirm their new AMEX credit card. It is because they have a lake of information about how to activate an American Express credit card. So now you don’t ever need to worry because confirmcard is providing the best solution to activate your AMEX card online and on the mobile phone as well.

  38. Jeesy Jones said:


  39. mahabhulekh said:

    thank you for sharing the details.

  40. Mymorri said:

    Thanks for sharing..

  41. payslipview said:

    Very nice stuff are always share here. I like this website very much. This comment is specially for your good job.

  42. Devesh Jain said:

    Instant Personal Loan Online

  43. manish kumar said:

    Book reviews, Short story, Samiksha, Technology, Science facts, Social talks, & Festivals much more. Which can be very motivated in your daily life.
    Best Book to be read in hindi!

  44. Lakshmi Associates said:

    nice work ,keep doing and sharing.

  45. Ailsa Wilson said:

    Working with best electric shower is a great experience. I am currently wiring with the electric shower and writing online reviews about the best electric shower.

  46. Ailsa Wilson said:

    So I am writing for the electric shower and best electric shower. I have a experience of writing the best online reviews as well.


  47. jordan said:

    To activate your American express card visit card and follow the activation process. You can also make a call on our number to confirm your card.

  48. timmy said:

    To activate your American express card visit card and follow the activation process. You can also make a call on our number to confirm your card.

  49. alpha said:

    To activate your American express card visit card and follow the activation process. You can also make a call on our number to confirm your card.

  50. WB Health Notification said:

    Good work and keep rocking.I have good website on jobs.

  51. wb-health-notification-2020 said:

    I Have a good website on the jobs.

  52. nimr-recruitment-2020 said:

    Good Job

  53. barkha verma said:

    nice article

  54. heaven jennifer said:

    Wow thanks for making this valuable stuff post I really impressed this stuff such a lovely content post
    cobra kai jacket

  55. Boots Payslip said:

    Thanks for making this blog for us.
    pertemps epay

  56. Mypal said:

    I really very happy to your all services.
    Thanks for sharing this blog with us.

  57. One Dasty said:

    Home Pug puppies and French Bulldogs make wonderful family pets. They are easygoing and get along well with children and the other pets of the household. Above all, they are Selecting a new pug puppy or French Bulldog is a daunting task.onality and is adaptable to your lifestyle.

  58. McOrlando said:

    All of Pitbull AKC registration contract that includes a basic health guarantee and a 3 year genetic health guarantee. They have been raised in our home around small children, kittens and dogs of every size to help them develop well round personalities accustomed to daily home activates. We encourage families to ask question and to stay in contact with us.
    All puppies sold as pets will go home spayed-neutered! We also sell puppies along with breeding right. Note this will an additional fee.

  59. The News Hack said:

    thanks for sharing this content

  60. Mymorri said:

    Thanks for sharing this. It’s really amazing.
    Tesco Payslips

  61. online vinyl shop said:

    thanks for sharing

  62. robert said:

    Throughout the years,exotic kittens and the occasional litter of gorgeous Bengals, Servals, Savannah and Caracal kittens.I did not have the time or the financial resource to devote to starting my own exotic kittens family encouraged me to pursue my dream and develop my own line of Exotic kittens.

  63. payslipview11 said:

    Thanks for sharing this blog .Amazing and informative site.good stuff always shared here. I like this website very much.very informative blog.also refer

  64. manrun said:

    Wow thanks for making this valuable stuff post I really impressed this stuff such a lovely content post

  65. Magnum Gold 24K said:

    such a nice information

  66. Magnum Gold 24K said:

    Thanks for information

  67. shro said:

    very nice post

  68. Timoza said:

    I really liked this essay and the way you presented it.

  69. Timoza said:

    Drift Boss online racing game challenges yourself to do things that no one else can do

  70. Mytyler said:

    Thanks for sharing this.

  71. alok verma said:

    thank you

  72. Ford said:

    Activate Credit Card is a website where you can get all the guidelines about how to activate a credit and debit card online. Especially if you are looing for Wells Fargo credit card activation.

    Activate Credit Card is a website where you can get all the information about how to activate a Wells Fargo credit card online. Use this information & get your card activated easily!

  73. Bridal dress said:

    Jazmin offers an amazing collection of ladies dupattas and dupatta design. Grab these stylish and trendy dupattas online today from These women’s dupatta designs are sure to bring attention and improve your wardrobe. Jazmin offers the best dupattas in Pakistan.

  74. WhizFortune said:

    This is a great blog but your blog is out dated would you consider redesigning the same?

  75. Sexologist in Delhi said:

    Health is one of the most crucial aspects of our lives that we have to take care of. We need to make sure that our body is free of any kind of disease or sickness. We also need to make sure that we are in the best of health and that we are doing the right thing to keep ourselves healthy. Therefore, finding the right treatment doctor is important. Treatment doctors are the ones who know the right way to relieve all our suffering. They are the ones who know how to treat our body and bring in the right kind of relief.

  76. API Matka said:

    Very knowledgeable article. Thank you for sharing your knowledge
    Satta Matka API
    Matka API auto result
    Matka API

  77. sienna miller coat anatomy of a scandal said:

    Hey. Very nice web site!! Man .. Excellent .. Wonderful .. I’ll bookmark this web site and take the feeds also…I am happy to locate so much helpful information here within the article. Thanks for sharing…

  78. Tim said:

    I like your article. It is full of updated information that I was looking for. This post saved my time in more searches. Keep sharing more content. Now it’s time to avail st albans locksmith for more information.

  79. barkha verma said:

    Thanks For The Information

  80. Shop ECS said:

    ECS welcome their customer to online shoes brand ECS which is offering best summer collections and new design which are of best quality.

  81. Commsec said:

    Thanks for sharing this amazing this Hellofresh Login

  82. Einthusan said:

    Nice Aru Canvas Login

  83. veda said:

    how to

  84. Jazmin said:

    Jazmin women clothing brands in pakistan provide best trendy dresses online. Jazmin is providing cost-effective and reliable lawn in market.

  85. Ayur treat said:

    Ayur Treat Ayurveda Clinic is one of the most trusted wellness clinic in the UAE where healing and caring begins. Being the best ayurvedic center in Dubai we approach each customer with holistic treatment methodologies and natural medicines.

  86. Alisha said:

    La Ilaaj lyrics – Arijit Singh : Get lyrics and music video of this beautiful song here on

  87. Rios Cosmetics said:

    : Rios is a multi-brand store providing amazing Lipsticks and lipstick shades The store aims to provide satisfaction through high quality products like lipstick colour Their lipstick shades are perfect and are just what you need Rios fulfills your every demand, with their items like Lipstick kits

  88. Ndure Shoes said:

    Get high quality branded shoes for men from Ndure today and style up for the summer.

  89. agus said:

    Pakai Link ini aja bebku di Jamin MAXWIN loh?, link scater jackpot ,Ada bocoran tips dan pola bermain nya juga loh, SCATTER isinya X100 X250 X500 nyamber trs??. Ingat begitu MAXWIN atau PROVIT lgsg WD,proses depo dan wd cepet banget ,di jamin gak bakal nyesel deh ,
    Ambil Bonus Mu Sekarang
    Claim melalui Live chat
    Deposit Bank Online 24jam
    Deposit All E-wallet
    minimal depo 20 ribu
    Deposit Pulsa Tanpa Potongan
    Turn Over Terendah 5X
    dengan WD yang di jamin cepat
    hub wa : 082160924564

  90. gil12 said:

    best Shisha in Dublin offers you a wide range of shisha with flavourful drinks to go with it. Bring in your friends and family and enjoy the secluded atmosphere we offer you. We are offering amazing deals on drinks and shisha combos throughout the week

  91. carlso12 said:

    We’ve created Ireland’s best team of software developers to build the mission-critical software that powers some of the world’s most successful companies. We solve their business problems through agile and cloud-native software innovation. They choose us because we offer the cutting-edge talent they need to change faster, easier, and more profitably; but they stay with us long term because we deliver every time.

  92. Kavin Sutton said:

    I am very pleased to have learned about the new version of your product. Thanks for sharing and providing good examples. Now I can use this immediately and improve my experience with our service. Cobra Kai Leather Jacket

  93. kamsiah said:

    Minimal deposit ke Bank 10 rb
    Minimal withdraw 25.rb
    Minimal deposit ke pulsa 10 rb tanpa potongan
    (syarat withdraw TO x5 khusus pulsa)
    Ayo bosku buruan deposit..
    dan juga kami ingin menginfokan kepada bosku semua nya
    Bahwasanya dalam permainan server slot PG Soft dan pragmatic play sedang banyak jackpot besar nya bos
    di coba kembali bermain bersama kami bosku ^^
    hanya dengan minimal deposit sebesar 10rb bosku bisa mendapatkan hadiah hingga puluan juta rupiah ^^

Leave a Reply