Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

What’s Better — Traditional or Self Publishing?

June 22nd, 2008 by Bob Bly

MF has written a nonfiction business book and wants to know whether I think it’s better to self-publish or look for a traditional publisher.

Here’s what I told MF….

If you want to establish your reputation as a though leader in your field, gain visibility, and build credibility, getting your book published by a mainstream publisher like McGraw-Hill or John Wiley is the best way to accomplish those goals. It is the most prestigious form of publishing, the one most likely to impress others.

If you want to maximize your revenues from sale of your book, I’d go with publishing it as an e-book. You can charge more than for a regular book, and your profit margin is much higher than with a printed book.

If you are a frequent speaker and need to get a book out on your topic quickly — to sell at your talks or to send to meeting planners to convince them to book you — a self-published printed book is the way to go.

A famous self-publishing guru once said in a speech that self-published books are no less prestigious than traditionally published books. “People don’t shop for a McGraw-Hill or a John Wiley book. They don’t care who the publisher is.”

True, but many people (not all) look down on self-publishing. Every self-publisher I know save one (the guru mentioned above) has confided in me that the moment they reveal their book is self published, they feel somehow embarrassed or apologetic.

Mainstream publisher for prestige … e-book for profit … traditional book for back of the room sales or a give-away to potential clients. That’s what I told MF. Do you agree with my assessment of her book publishing options?


This entry was posted on Sunday, June 22nd, 2008 at 2:45 pm and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

43 responses about “What’s Better — Traditional or Self Publishing?”

  1. ElizabethAdamsDirect said:

    ebook for profit … providing a marketing machine is feasible … launch, lists, adwords, buzz, etc.

  2. dianacacy said:

    I hang out with writers both publishing in the traditional field and self-publishing. Both avenues work, and I feel you gave a very good response on it.

    Self-publishing’s reputation has been damaged by the unethical practices of the dishonest self-publishing/POD service providers. It not only makes the honest service providers have to work twice as hard to prove themselves, it leads many writers groups to recommend to all new writers to avoid them completely.

    Also, to add to the benefits of publishing your own e-books. Even in genres and occasions where you charge less for an e-book than you would a printed book, you get to keep more of the money generated from the sale per book.

    I think which avenue a writer takes is dependent upon what and how much that writer is willing to undertake in the marketing of the finished product. And if it’s a one shot deal or if the writer will continually produce more e-books.

  3. ElizabethAdamsDirect said:

    then there’s the little matter of breaking into publishing … maybe a dozen ebooks or so under your belt would give you a leg up …

  4. ElizabethAdamsDirect said:

    Bob, there’s a plug-in that lets people put a check in a box so they get email notifications of comments … just a suggestion …

  5. Kristi Holl said:

    Self-publishing’s reputation hasn’t just been damaged by unethical practices, although that’s certainly true. Most self-publishing is pretty substandard, which is why bookstores won’t stock many, if any, titles. They tend to be rushed, barely edited or critiqued, and with art work that isn’t the best. I know there are exceptions–I’ve seen a few–but for the most part this is why self-publishing has a bad reputation.

  6. Jim Logan said:

    I agree with your recommendation Bob: mainstream for prestige, ebook for profit and self-publish for promotion.

    I have a friend who self-publishes books in support of speaking opportunities. He’s very successful with his books as a lead generator. Also, he’s successfully sold many copies on Amazon. His books look, feel and read like a book published by McGraw-Hill or John Wiley. I believe he uses Lulu to publish.

    That said, I agree with you and it’s the advice I offer to friends and clients.

  7. dianacacy said:

    Self-publishing is still a great way to get your work to the readers. Authors send me copies of their books for reviews, and what Kristi says is true.

    I think anyone considering self-publishing has to keep in mind that people are not going to enjoy something that looks like second-class material. They want first class. They expect more than their money’s worth.

    Always produce the best product you can and go for the repeat sales.

    Tell them to do more than just kick out the e-books. Tell them to kick out QUALITY e-books, and they’ll get the respect they’re looking for.

    BTW, Bob, in case you were wondering if anyone else knows about that checkbox that Elizabeth mentioned … I did look for it. I have your blog on my google reader, but can’t follow a single comment thread through it, so I would have needed that checkbox.

  8. dianacacy said:

    I’m not sure this is on-topic, but this subject did make me think of this.

    Bob, I keep your Copywriter’s Handbook close to me. I refer back to it often. So often that my copy is getting pretty worn already. And I know others in the same situation with your book.

    Have you ever thought about releasing the book in a tough page, spiral format for quick and constant reference? If you have the rights freedom to do that, it could be an option.

    I have a few other of your books and some of the e-books, but that’s the one getting the most abuse from me.

  9. Bob Bly said:

    Dianacacy: The Copywriter’s Handbook is published by Henry Holt & Company. They are a traditional publisher and therefore are only going to publish it as a standard trade paperback (the first edition way back in 1985 was also a hardcover). Only self-publishers have the option of special formats, which is another advantage of self-publishing traditional publishers do not offer.

  10. dianacacy said:

    Thanks, Bob …

    I was afraid that would be your answer. Figured it wouldn’t hurt to ask though. LOL

  11. Barney Davey said:

    I am a successful self-published author. My book after 3 years regularly ranks in Amazon’s top 20 Business of Art category. I would not trade the 16:1 difference in revenue to have a traditional publisher for any reason. Further, I have never felt any shame in self-publishing. Rather, I’m quite proud I was able to do achieve success through my own efforts. My book was selected for the prestigious North Light Book Club. Apparently, it was not bothered by the fact the book is self-published.

    The development of POD (Print-on-demand) technology and the Internet make this the best time ever to be an author, artist or musician. My blog post today is titled Indie Art Intersection. If the revenue were more equitable, I still doubt I would use a traditional publisher. It’s old school.

  12. S.P. Gass said:

    Does the same advice apply to fiction? I am writing my first novel and plan to try traditional publishing agents for a couple of months. If I do not get a response, then I’ll self-publish. Does that approach make sense?


  13. Barney Davey said:

    I am a self-published author and proud of it. Shame or embarrassment never crossed my mind. My book has steadily remained in Amazon’s Top 20 Business of Art category for three years. It was ordered and reordered by the North Light Book ClubI I net nearly $18 for each copy sold and do zero fulfillment. A traditional publisher might pay $1.00 per copy. I would be far more ashamed to be taking such a financial beating from the traditional publishing model.

    In my blog post today, title Indie Art Intersection, I talk about how POD (Print-on-demand) and the Internet have given artists, authors and musicians more opportunities to create their own success than ever before. If you have it in you, go for it. If you don’t, or you are hidebound to faltering traditional distribution models hang in, but don’t complain either.

  14. Bob Bly said:

    Barney: congratulations on your success. Choice of publishing mode (traditional, self-published, e-books) depends on several factors. I always went with a traditional publisher for two reasons. First, I did not have the time, temperment, or talent for self-publishing. Second, I wrote books to establish myself as a guru in my field (direct response copywriting), and potential clients were impressed that I was able to get big publishers to publish my books.

  15. Corwin said:

    We all immediately recognize the flat snoot, wrinkled face, and large during the time of Confucius, when the breed was known as lo-sze. Imported to England in the 16th century, the breed quickly became a popular lap dog among the aristocracy. A Pug named Pompey is even credited with alerting Holland’s William I, Prince of Orange, to an assassination attempt by Spain. Over time, pugs have been the favored breed or both royals and celebrities—from Napoleon and Queen Victoria to Andy Warhol and Rob Zombie.

  16. Frank Lehman said:

    I finally found a hobby that really makes video games fun and there is a cool site that helps me rank higher in all the top games.

  17. DariaJane said:

    Do you believe that there are games in the eyes of others that are just useless or even harmful things that can save a soul? I was having a really hard time and I asked the stickman fighter for an action game that pulled me out of the swamp.

  18. Silajay said:

    Have you ever played a puzzle game? You have cleared all the puzzle games but the level of the game is out. Then you need Octordle. Puzzle game with high difficulty constantly updated. There are 2 ways to play for you to choose to learn more at Octordle

  19. Nawaz said:

    Great post,It is really very informative post for young people and hope they will enjoy well after reading this post. Thanks for sharing.Thanks for this post.
    Get enroll in amazon wholesale fba course

  20. kritz filme said:

    i think tradicional is much better because McGraw is no a goo movie.

  21. Evenementenbureau uitjes in Alkmaar said:

    Evenementenbureau Alkmaar biedt de leukste uitjes die u zich kunt voorstellen. Van spannende wandelingen tot onvergetelijke boottochten, ze hebben het allemaal! Uitjes zijn een geweldige manier om te ontspannen, nieuwe plekken te ontdekken en te genieten van quality time met vrienden en familie. Evenementenbureau Alkmaar stemt elk uitje af op uw specifieke wensen en voorkeuren; daarom behoren hun diensten tot de beste in de regio. Of u nu op zoek bent naar een avontuur, professionele begeleiding of gewoon even weg wilt uit het dagelijkse leven – Evenementenbureau Alkmaar zorgt ervoor dat uw uitje er één voor in de boeken wordt!

  22. Woonadvies Noord-Holland said:

    Noord-Holland is een populaire plek voor zowel toeristen als inwoners, maar het kan moeilijk zijn om betrouwbaar woonadvies te vinden in het gebied. Gelukkig biedt Woonadvies Noord-Hollanders de beste bronnen die ze nodig hebben om de juiste beslissingen te nemen met betrekking tot hun woonwensen. Van gedetailleerde overzichten van verschillende vastgoedopties tot deskundige adviezen over welke gebieden de meest betrouwbare voorzieningen of de hoogste huurprijzen hebben, Woonadvies helpt Noord-Hollanders slimme keuzes te maken als het gaat om hun ideale woonruimte. Of ze nu op zoek zijn naar een huis, appartement of loft om te huren of te kopen, Noord-Hollanders kunnen erop vertrouwen dat Woonadvies de middelen heeft die nodig zijn om ze in hun nieuwe onderkomen te krijgen in Kennemerland voordat ze het weten.

  23. Lash Melbourne said:

    I am incapable of reading articles online very often, but I’m happy I did today. It is very well written, and your points are well-expressed. I request you warmly, please, don’t ever stop writing.

  24. Natuurgeneeskunde voeding West-Friesland said:

    Natuurgeneeskunde is een systeem van geneeskunde dat zich richt op de natuur en het natuurlijke genezingsvermogen van het lichaam. Natuurgeneeskundige voeding is een tak van natuurgeneeskunde die zich richt op voeding en de manier waarop deze kan worden gebruikt om de gezondheid te bevorderen en het lichaam te genezen.Natuurgeneeskundige voedingsdeskundigen geloven dat voeding een medicijn is en dat wat we eten een directe invloed heeft op onze gezondheid. Ze werken om mensen voor te lichten over het belang van het eten van een voedzaam dieet en het kiezen van gezond voedsel.West-Friesland is een regio in Nederland die bekend staat om zijn prachtige landschappen en zijn traditionele melkveebedrijven. De regio is ook de thuisbasis van veel natuurgeneeskundigen die voeding gebruiken om gezondheid en welzijn te bevorderen.

  25. Seo Expret said:

    I’m going to read this. I’ll be sure to come back. thanks for sharing. and also This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. this is very nice one and gives indepth information. thanks for this nice article… slot gacor777

  26. Goedkoop ongebleekt katoen said:

    Ongebleekt katoen wordt een steeds populairdere stof vanwege de vele voordelen. In tegenstelling tot gewoon katoen, dat vaak met agressieve chemicaliën wordt behandeld, is ongebleekt katoen natuurlijk biologisch en vrij van potentieel schadelijke behandelingen. Het robuuste weefsel betekent ook dat het extra duurzaam is en meerdere wasbeurten kan doorstaan zonder te scheuren of te verbleken. Bovendien wordt het gemaakt met behulp van een unieke waterbesparende techniek die extra kleurstoffen overbodig maakt, waardoor het niet alleen een gezondere maar ook een milieuvriendelijke optie is! Ongebleekt katoen is ideaal voor kleding die lang mee moet gaan.

  27. Steiger transportbokken said:

    Een transportbok is een indrukwekkend staaltje techniek, en het is een essentieel stukje technologie sinds ze voor het eerst werden uitgevonden. Ze bestaan uit een grote steiger, die lange afstanden over land of water kan overbruggen. Transportbokken worden meestal gebruikt om zware ladingen vracht of mensen van de ene plaats naar de andere te vervoeren. In sommige gevallen zijn zij de ruggengraat van de infrastructuur van een stad geworden en bieden zij de inwoners een betrouwbare en veilige toegang tot het verkeer. In steden met transportschragen is het gebruikelijk om er luxueuze woonwijken langs te vinden en goed onderhouden paden voor voetgangers en fietsers. Dit toont aan dat er iets speciaals is aan dit soort constructies – meer dan alleen technische kunst; er is ook schoonheid en comfort.

  28. said:

    i really like this article please keep it up.

  29. jackseo said:

    Thanks a lot for sharing this excellent info! I am looking forward to seeing more posts by you as soon as possible! I have judged that you do not compromise on quality. when google bot visit my site

  30. Kosten Matrassen laten reinigen said:

    Reinigen van uw matras is essentieel voor een gezond, schoon en comfortabel nachtrust. Reiniging help om vuil, stof, mijten en allerlei bacteriën te verwijderen die zich over de loop der jaren hebben verzameld in je matras en kussensloop. Het laten reinigen van je matrassen is een geweldige manier om ervoor te zorgen dat je jezelf elke nacht comfortabel neer kan leggen en dat je slaapkamer gezond blijft. Om optimale resultaten te behalen met reinigen is het belangrijk om een professionele bedrijf in te schakelen. Zij beschikken over de juiste tools en technieken om de matrassen grondig schoon te maken. Reinige matrassen leiden tot betere hygiëne, een betere algehele gezondheid en meer comfort terwijl je slaapt!

  31. jackseo said:

    I’m glad to see the great detail here!. Promotional short video Ads

  32. jackseo said:

    If you set out to make me think today; mission accomplished! I really like your writing style and how you express your ideas. Thank you.

  33. Seo Expret said:

    This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. rolex watches high copy

  34. Buongiornando said:

    Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article.

  35. jackseo said:

    You made such an interesting piece to read, giving every subject enlightenment for us to gain knowledge. Thanks for sharing the such information with us to read this…

  36. Liwovosa said:

    Het gebruik van een IBAN-naamcontrole is een geweldige manier om de intentie van internationale betalingen en overschrijvingen te verifiëren. Het garandeert niet alleen dat de betaling correct wordt ontvangen door informatie zoals het bankrekeningnummer van de ontvanger te bevestigen, maar het stelt mensen die geld versturen ook in staat om het gemakkelijk te lokaliseren en te beschermen tegen ongeoorloofde pogingen tot verdubbeling. Daarom implementeren banken, FinTechs en andere organisaties vaak IBAN-naamcontroles als onderdeel van hun proces – waardoor ze risicobeoordelingen kunnen uitvoeren voordat ze transacties goedkeuren. Door gebruik te maken van dit handige hulpmiddel kunnen degenen die geld overmaken veilig zijn in de wetenschap dat alle gegevens snel en veilig worden geverifieerd – waardoor ze de gemoedsrust hebben dat hun betaling veilig op de plaats van bestemming aankomt. IBAN-naam check medewerker sollicitant

  37. johnyking said:

    I personally use them exclusively high-quality elements : you will notice these folks during: my thc vape pens

  38. Liwovosa said:

    It is a great website.. The Design looks very good.. Keep working like that!. forbes up

  39. kamsiah said:

    Minimal deposit ke Bank 10 rb
    Minimal withdraw 25.rb
    Minimal deposit ke pulsa 10 rb tanpa potongan
    (syarat withdraw TO x5 khusus pulsa)
    Ayo bosku buruan deposit..
    dan juga kami ingin menginfokan kepada bosku semua nya
    Bahwasanya dalam permainan server slot PG Soft dan pragmatic play sedang banyak jackpot besar nya bos
    di coba kembali bermain bersama kami bosku ^^
    hanya dengan minimal deposit sebesar 10rb bosku bisa mendapatkan hadiah hingga puluan juta rupiah ^^

  40. rosy dam said:

    I concur with Bob’s advice: self-publish for marketing, ebook for profit, and mainstream for prestige.My friend self-publishes books in order to smile dating test fund speaking engagements. He has great success generating leads with his publications.

  41. Liwovosa said:

    Wow, cool post. I’d like to write like this too – taking time and real hard work to make a great article… but I put things off too much and never seem to get started. Thanks though. ??????? ???????

  42. Liwovosa said:

    Indoor evenementen in Amsterdam zijn enkele van de meest opwindende en unieke ervaringen die je kunt plannen voor je vrije tijd. Van het verkennen van musea tot het bezoeken van chique cafés, Amsterdam biedt een breed scala aan indoor activiteiten. Met honderden activiteiten verspreid over de stad vindt u zeker iets dat zowel leuk als memorabel is, of u nu een uitje met vrienden of familie plant. Binnenactiviteiten bieden bezoekers volop vermaak, waaronder galeries, theaters, winkels en zelfs bibliotheken! Avonturiers zullen ook de Amsterdam Dungeon spannend vinden, terwijl degenen die op zoek zijn naar een verfijnde ervaring een van de vele restaurants kunnen bezoeken die vertrouwd zijn bij zowel toeristen als de lokale bevolking. Indoor evenementen in Amsterdam hebben echt voor elk wat wils – waarom niet profiteren? Binnen uitjes Amsterdam

  43. Liwovosa said:

    Where would any organization be without its team? Good teambuilding is key for teams of all kinds, from sports teams to businesses! Groepsuitjes, such as a company outing or a local event organized by the vereniging, offer a great opportunity for team members to get to know each other better. They can help foster interaction between those who don’t normally work together and otherwise may not have had the chance to become friends. Through games and activities during these events, colleagues in the same organization can strengthen their bond and boost morale with fun outings. With these ties strengthened, team members will be ready to tackle anything with greater efficiency and success! Indoor teambuilding company outings

Leave a Reply